Equalities among simplest quartic fields: a complete classification

Abstract

For a positive integer $n$, let $f_n(X)=X^4-n{X}^3-6X^2+nX+1$ and let $K_n=\mathbb{Q}({\rho }_n)$, where ${\rho }_n$ is a root of $f_n$. We determine all coincidences among these fields: for distinct positive integers $m,n$, $K_m=K_n⟺\{m,n\}\in \{\{1,103\},\{2,22\},\{4,956\}\}$. Thus the three previously known equalities are the only ones. This extends Hoshi's finite-range classification to all positive integral parameters and, in particular, subsumes the uniqueness results of Pincus and Washington. The proof combines Hoshi's correspondence between equal simplest quartic fields and primitive solutions of a quartic Thue equation with estimates of Lettl--Pethő--Voutier for rational approximations to two of its real roots. A Gaussian-integer identity yields a lower bound for the denominator of the resulting rational approximation; the continued-fraction information and the approximation estimates then exclude every parameter exceeding $1000$.

8 pages; added references to earlier work of M.-N. Gras and clarified historical attribution; added a declaration of AI use; main results unchanged