An Explicit Counterexample to Stanley's Rankwise Lower-Bound Conjecture for Differential Posets

Abstract

In Problem 6 of his 1988 paper on differential posets, Stanley asked for the least possible cardinality of a fixed rank of an $r$-differential poset and suggested that the minimum should be attained by $Y^r$, the $r$-fold Cartesian power of Young's lattice. We disprove the resulting universal coefficientwise lower bound. For every $r\ge 3$, we construct an infinite $r$-differential poset $P^{(r)}$ satisfying $|P_4^{(r)}|=|(Y^r{)}_4|-\lfloor r/3\rfloor$. For $r=3$, the construction replaces thirteen rank-four lower-cover blocks of $Y^3$ by twelve blocks with the same point and pair incidence multiplicities, producing the initial rank sequence $1,3,9,22,50$ instead of $1,3,9,22,51$. A reflection extension then yields an infinite differential poset. The construction does not address the cases $r=1$ and $r=2$.