Beyond $j=1$: Observational Constraints on Almost-$\hat{I}›$CDM Cosmologies

Abstract

The cosmographic condition $j(z)=1$ provides the kinematical signature of the spatially flat $\hat{I}›$CDM model independently of any specific dark-energy or modified-gravity theory. We investigate the extent to which current observations permit departures from this condition by considering three phenomenological ``almost-$\hat{I}›$CDM'' cosmographic closures, in which the cosmic jerk differs slightly from unity through a small deformation parameter $\hat{I}\mu$. The models are constrained using Markov Chain Monte Carlo analyses of recent DESI baryon acoustic oscillation measurements together with compressed Planck cosmic microwave background likelihoods and the Union3, Pantheon+, and DESY5 Type Ia supernova compilations. Rather than assuming a parameterized dark-energy equation of state, our cosmographic framework reconstructs the expansion history directly from observations, with the effective dark-energy equation of state emerging as a derived quantity. We find that all three closures are tightly constrained to the vicinity of the $\hat{I}›$CDM cosmographic fixed point, with Planck data driving the preferred evolution toward $j_0\simeq 1$ and $w_{\mathrm{DE},0}\simeq -1$. Despite their distinct kinematical constructions, the reconstructed dark-energy evolution consistently exhibits smooth freezing behaviour close to $w=-1$, without crossing the phantom divide. Model comparison using the Akaike and Bayesian information criteria shows that the almost-$\hat{I}›$CDM models remain statistically competitive with standard dark-energy parameterizations while requiring fewer assumptions about the functional form of $w(z)$. These results demonstrate the power of model-independent cosmography for constraining the cosmic expansion history and provide a natural framework for future studies of cosmological perturbations and structure formation.

7 figures, 5 tables