TOPSIS-RAD: Ranking According to Desires
arXiv:2606.07253
Abstract
Traditional TOPSIS derives its reference points -- the Positive Ideal Solution () and Negative Ideal Solution () -- from the observed alternative set, making rankings susceptible to misalignment with decision-maker (DM) requirements, sensitivity to outlier performances, and rank reversal. This paper proposes TOPSIS-RAD, which addresses these issues by incorporating two arrays of DM-defined reference levels. Vetoed Performance Levels () exclude non-viable alternatives before normalisation, preventing them from distorting the ranking frontiers. Desired Performance Levels () cap performances at the DM's desired level before normalisation, anchoring the in explicit aspirations rather than dataset extremes. Three toy examples demonstrate each mechanism: reshapes normalisation boundaries by removing a non-viable alternative; fixed frontiers stabilise rankings by limiting the influence of performances well above the desired level. The method preserves the familiar distance-based structure of TOPSIS while grounding the ranking in stable, DM-specified boundaries. Limitations and future research directions are also discussed.
arXiv comment21 pages, 15 Tables and 6 figures. The numerical computation of the data that appear in the Toy Examples was Supported by the Visual TOPSIS RAD that is available at https://topsis-ranking.vercel.app/. The data of the Toy examples are also available in this URL and can be loaded in the app as the template "Article"