Schedule-dependent basin occupation and instance-specific effective scales in cycled reverse annealing on programmable quantum annealers

Abstract

Reverse annealing initializes a programmable quantum annealer in a chosen classical state, reintroduces quantum fluctuations down to a pause point, and returns to readout; repeated cycles form a configurable dissipative dynamics whose schedule knobs are routinely treated as a temperature. On mixed-frustration 12-qubit Ising instances on two D-Wave generations (Advantage2 and Advantage_system6.4), we measure schedule-driven redistribution of the subsystem readout and calibrate each schedule's effective scales, using exhaustive enumeration of the $2^{12}$ configurations, a locked analysis plan with a prior-knowledge disclosure, and regenerated classical reference families. First, schedule shape redistributes basin occupation: 11 of 20 random instances respond to a single-pause-to-two-pause change (15 of 20 for long-hold; block permutation, FDR-controlled), with shifts up to 38 percentage points and changes of dominant-configuration identity. Second, the single-qubit probe temperature does not transfer to the many-body problem: moment-matched inverse temperatures span 0.63-9.1 against a probe value of 7.22, and pause depth and duration each shift the scale on most instances (19/20 and 15/20). Third, no observation requires more than the tested classical families: with update budgets extended below one sweep per cycle, all 33 (device, instance, schedule) cells are reproduced within the tested family (minimum intersection-union $p=0.76$), and schedule-aware spin-vector Monte Carlo brings the late-window statistics within semiclassical reach. A pre-registered linear predictor fails on held-out instances, and an earlier pilot's two-pause enhancement claim is contradicted (Fisher $p=0.0013$). Reverse-anneal schedules are instance-specific basin-occupation controls whose effective scales must be calibrated per instance and schedule; nothing here licenses a quantum-mechanistic reading.

v3: substantive correction; v2's central claims are withdrawn (matched-temperature PT/SQA bracket, 3/18 PT-unmatched count, native-graph replication) after an internal reanalysis found calibration, units, estimator, and gauge-frame errors. All analyses regenerated under a locked prespecified plan; raw QPU records unchanged. Full details in the Note on version 3, page 1. 32 pages, 7 figures