An Algebraic Resolution of the Firewall Paradox

Abstract

The AMPS firewall argument relies on treating early radiation, late outgoing Hawking modes, and interior partner modes as approximately independent quantum subsystems. In diffeomorphism-invariant quantum gravity, however, gravitational dressing and asymptotic constraints obstruct such a tensor-product factorization of physical observables. In this essay, we sharpen this obstruction by formulating subsystem independence directly in operator-algebraic terms. Using modular theory, half-sided modular inclusions along null directions, and the sector-wise maximality of the dressed radiation algebra at future null infinity, we show that -- within a fixed asymptotic charge sector -- the algebra associated with the interior Hawking partner cannot form an independent commuting subalgebra, but must be contained as a (non-commuting) subalgebra of the radiation algebra itself. The subsystem-independence assumption underlying the AMPS paradox therefore fails, and the entanglement-monogamy step never becomes applicable. As a result, unitary black hole evaporation and semiclassical horizon smoothness are compatible in asymptotically flat quantum gravity, without invoking entanglement islands, replica wormholes, or modifications of semiclassical horizon physics.

arXiv commentHonorable Mention, Gravity Research Foundation Awards for Essays on Gravitation 2026. An expanded version, including a discussion of island physics, has been accepted for publication in International Journal of Modern Physics D as part of the special issue on the Gravity Research Foundation Awards 2026