Response to the He interpretation of MAMI's recent determination of H)
arXiv:2604.27748
Abstract
We respond to the recent suggestion by A. Gal [arXiv:2604.18259] that the sharp pion-momentum peak at ~MeV/ observed in our electroproduction experiment at MAMI [Phys. Rev. Lett. 136, 152301 (2026)] originates from weak decay rather than from as we reported. We present quantitative arguments against this interpretation and conclude that the assignment remains the most well-supported interpretation of the data.