Comment on "Quantum phase transitions of Dirac particles in a magnetized rotating curved background: Interplay of geometry, magnetization, and thermodynamics"

Abstract

In this comment, we obtain the complete energy spectra for the paper by Sahan et al. [1], that is, the energy spectra dependent on two quantum numbers, namely, the radial quantum number (given by $n\ge 0$) and the angular quantum number (given by $m\ne 0$). In particular, what motivated us to carry out such a study was the fact that the quantized energy spectra for Dirac particles in a curved or flat spacetime in polar coordinates explicitly depend on two quantum numbers. From this, the following question arose: Why do the energy spectra in the paper by Sahan et al. [1] depends on only one quantum number and not two, given that they worked with the Dirac equation in polar coordinates? So, using several important papers in the literature on the Dirac equation in curved spacetimes, as well as the most commonly used definition for Dirac gamma matrices in (2+1)-dimensions, we corrected some minor errors in the paper by Sahan et al. [1]. Consequently, we obtain the true second-order differential equation for their problem, as well as the complete energy spectra, which explicitly depend on both $n$ and $m$. Finally, we note that for $m<0$ (negative angular momentum) with $s=-1$ (lower component of the Dirac spinor), we obtain (except for one term with the incorrect sign) the particular energy spectra of Sahan et al. [1].

9 pages, no figure. Comment on arXiv:2409.18535

References in corpus (26)

• Exact Mapping of the 2+1 Dirac Oscillator onto the Jaynes-Cummings Model: Ion-Trap Experimental Proposal
• Interacting fermions in rotation: chiral symmetry restoration, moment of inertia and thermodynamics
• On the interaction of the Dirac oscillator with the Aharonov-Casher system in topological defect backgrounds
• Rotating effects on the Dirac oscillator in the cosmic string spacetime
• Energy spectrum of a 2D Dirac electron in the presence of a constant magnetic field
• Relativistic quantum oscillators in the global monopole spacetime
• Boundary effects and gapped dispersion in rotating fermionic matter
• Exact solution of the two-dimensional Dirac oscillator
• Dirac oscillator in an external magnetic field
• Exact solutions of the (2+1) Dimensional Dirac equation in a constant magnetic field in the presence of a minimal length
• Energy Spectrum of a 2D Dirac Oscillator in the Presence of the Aharonov-Bohm Effect
• Quantum simulation of Hawking radiation and curved spacetime with a superconducting on-chip black hole
• Effects of spin on the dynamics of the 2D Dirac oscillator in the magnetic cosmic string background
• Three-dimensional Dirac oscillator in a thermal bath
• The phase of a quantum mechanical particle in curved spacetime
• Dirac Equation in (1+1)-Dimensional Curved Spacetime and the Multiphoton Quantum Rabi Model
• Inverse magneto-rotational catalysis and the phase diagram of a rotating hot and magnetized quark matter
• Bound state solutions of the Dirac oscillator in an Aharonov-Bohm-Coulomb system
• Dirac Equation Studies in the Tunnelling Energy Zone
• The noncommutative quantum Hall effect with anomalous magnetic moment in three different relativistic scenarios
• An innovative model for coupled fermion-antifermion pairs
• Relativistic and nonrelativistic Landau levels for the noncommutative quantum Hall effect with anomalous magnetic moment in a conical Gödel-type spacetime
• The Dirac point electron in zero-gravity Kerr--Newman spacetime
• Dirac fermions in a spinning conical Gödel-type spacetime
• Dirac-isotonic oscillators in (1 + 1) and (2 + 1) dimensions
• Comment on "Neutrino interaction with matter in a noninertial frame"