Revisiting the Excess of Bar-like Structures in TNG50 Early-type Galaxies: Consistency and Tension with Observations

Abstract

The IllustrisTNG simulation suite, particularly TNG50, was reported to have generated a notable population of elongated, bar-like structures within galaxies classified as Early-Type Galaxies (ETGs). In this work, we revisit the nature of these structures at $z=0$ using a morphology-agnostic census. We find that these features are ubiquitous ($f_{\mathrm{bar}}\sim 75-80\%$) in dispersion-dominated galaxies ($D/T<0.2$) in TNG50-1. They are not prolate rotators (rotating around their long axis), but genuine non-axisymmetric instabilities characterized by coherent, albeit slow, pattern speeds. Unlike the fast bars found in Late-Type Galaxies, these bar-like structures in ETGs are physically longer ($\gtrsim 3$ kpc), rotate significantly slower (${\Omega }_p\lesssim 20$ km s${}^{-1}$ kpc${}^{-1}$), and reside in red, gas-poor, dispersion-dominated systems. By tracing the evolutionary history of these systems, we demonstrate that such structures originate as typical fast bars in gas-richer discs at higher redshifts ($z\gtrsim 0.2$). They survive the galaxy quenching phase, undergoing secular deceleration and lengthening due to dynamical friction, ultimately appearing as slow, fossilized rotators in the $z=0$ red sequence. We conclude that the specific excess of bar-like structures in TNG50 ETGs likely reflects a combination of the imperfect baryonic physics of the simulation (over-producing these bar-like structures or their host ETGs) and a potential observational blind spot regarding long-lived, secularly evolved bars in hot stellar systems.

16 pages, 6 figures, accepted for publication in Research in Astronomy and Astrophysics. Companion paper: arXiv:2603.05287. Project page: https://hangcidu.github.io/early-type_bars/