Isometric Incompatibility in Growing Elastic Sheets

Abstract

Geometric incompatibility, the inability of a material's rest state to be realized in Euclidean space, underlies shape formation in natural and synthetic thin sheets. Classical Gauss and Mainardi-Codazzi-Peterson (MCP) incompatibilities explain many patterns in nature, but they do not exhaust the mechanisms that frustrate thin elastic sheets. We identify a new incompatibility that forbids smooth stretching-free configurations, even when the rest state of the elastic sheet locally satisfies the Gauss and MCP compatibility conditions. We demonstrate this principle in a model of surface growth with positive Gaussian curvature, where a geometric horizon forms, leading to the onset of frustration. Experiments, simulations, and theory show that the sheet responds by nucleating periodic d-cone-like dimples. We show that this obstruction to stretching-free configurations is topological, and we point to open questions concerning the origin of frustration.

7 pages, 4 figures. Published in Phys. Rev. Lett. 137, 058201 (2026)

References in corpus (13)

• Elastic theory of unconstrained non-Euclidean plates
• Morphogenesis of growing soft tissues
• Wrapping an adhesive sphere with a sheet
• Geometrically incompatible confinement of solids
• A Riemannian Approach to Reduced Plate, Shell, and Rod Theories
• Frustrated Self-Assembly of Non-Euclidean Crystals of Nanoparticles
• Metric Description of Defects in Amorphous Materials
• Oscillating membranes: modeling and controlling autonomous shape-transforming sheets
• Dynamics, scaling behavior, and control of nuclear wrinkling
• Topological elasticity of non-orientable ribbons
• Fractional solitons in non-Euclidian elastic plates
• Crumples as a generic stress-focusing instability in confined sheets
• Nonlinear mechanics of rigidifying curves