Fair Division with Soft Conflicts

Abstract

We study the fair division of indivisible goods with conflicts between pairs of goods, represented by a graph $G=(V,E)$. We consider ``soft'' conflicts: assigning two adjacent goods to the same agent is allowed, but we seek allocations that are envy-free up to one good (EF1) while keeping the number of such conflict violations small. We propose a linear-time algorithm for general additive valuations that finds an EF1 allocation with at most $|E|/n+O(|E{|}^{1-1/(2n-2)})$ violations, for any constant number of agents $n$. The leading term $|E|/n$ matches the worst-case bound on the number of violations. We use a novel approach that combines an algorithm for fair division with cardinality constraints from Biswas \& Barman (2018) and a geometric ``closest points'' argument. For identical additive valuations, we also propose a simple round-robin-based algorithm that finds an EF1 allocation with at most $|E|/n$ violations.

16 pages