Residual Symmetries and Scalar Multiplet Vacuum Alignment in Non-Abelian Flavour Models

Abstract

We demonstrate that, upon minimizing a renormalizable, single-scalar potential invariant under a non-Abelian symmetry, special orientations in the associated vacuum alignment of the scalar multiplet correspond to the preservation of a discrete residual flavour symmetry in the broken phase of the theory. Conversely, we show that these special scalar alignments are perturbed when additional Lagrangian operators (e.g. renormalizable, multi-flavon operators and/or effective, higher-dimensional operators) are present that break said residual symmetry, leading to a vacuum reorientation and phenomenological consequences. We therefore construct a one-to-one correspondence principle between broken residual symmetries and vacuum alignment corrections, providing a mechanism to identify (and correct) a subtle but persistent form of phenomenologically relevant fine-tuning embedded in -- but often ignored by -- most successful non-Abelian flavour models. We first establish this correspondence in a set of toy models based on the S4 permutation symmetry, and then apply the lessons learned to the more realistic A4 Altarelli-Feruglio and $\Delta (27)$ Universal Texture Zero models.

24 pages, Version accepted for publication in JHEP

References in corpus (13)

• Neutrino tri-bi-maximal mixing from a non-Abelian discrete family symmetry
• Symmetry of Lepton Mixing
• The Flavor Group Delta(3n^2)
• Lepton Mixing Patterns from a Scan of Finite Discrete Groups
• On the origin of neutrino flavour symmetry
• Classification of lepton mixing matrices from finite residual symmetries
• On The Potential of Minimal Flavour Violation
• [Re]constructing Finite Flavour Groups: Horizontal Symmetry Scans from the Bottom-Up
• Discrete flavour symmetries for degenerate solar neutrino pair and their predictions
• Exploring multi-Higgs models with softly broken large discrete symmetry groups
• Discrete symmetries and Efficient Counting of Operators
• Froggatt-Nielsen Meets the SMEFT
• Revisiting the Universal Texture Zero of Flavour: a Markov Chain Monte Carlo Analysis