Free Independence is not definable

Abstract

Free independence is an important tool for studying the structure of operator algebras. It is natural to ask from the model-theoretic standpoint whether free independence is captured well in first-order model theory via the notion of a definable set. We prove that pairs of freely independent elements do not form a definable set in the sense of continuous model theory, relative to the theory of both C${}^{\ast }$-probability spaces and tracial von Neumann algebras.

Author-accepted manuscript; to appear in "Involve, a Journal of Mathematics"