Sharp Hybrid Confidence Bands for Partially Identified Treatment Effects under Tail Uncertainty with an Application to Workforce Gender Diversity and Firm Performance

Abstract

Manski's nonparametric bounds partially identify the average treatment effects (ATEs) under minimal assumptions, yielding an interval-valued estimand with endpoints that depend on the outcome support - typically treated as known or fixed. In many empirical settings, however, credible bounds on the outcome support are often unavailable and outcomes may be heavy-tailed, so common empirical implementations that rely on ad-hoc truncation or observed extrema can compromise finite-sample coverage. We develop concATE, a hybrid confidence band for interval-identified ATEs that explicitly accounts for tail uncertainty without imposing parametric assumptions. The inference method combines a distribution-free concentration bound for the outcome distribution based on the Dvoretzky-Kiefer-Wolfowitz inequality with the asymptotic delta-method inference for smooth mean components, and allocates size across bound endpoints using Bonferroni's inequality to guarantee joint coverage. We further extend concATE to a group-sequential procedure that controls the family-wise error rate using Pocock correction. Applying the method to panel data on 901 listed firms (2015Q2--2022Q1), we find that senior-level gender diversity has a statistically significant positive effect on firm value (Tobin's Q) only after crossing substantial representation thresholds: in Growth & Innovation sectors, significance emerges at approximately 55% female leadership, while in Defensive sectors it appears only beyond about 60%.