Categorical-algebraic aspects of Heyting semilattices
arXiv:2508.11250 · doi:10.1016/j.apal.2026.103823
Abstract
This article gives an overview of some key categorical-algebraic properties of the variety of Heyting semilattices, with the aim of correcting a misconception in the literature. We confirm that the category of Heyting semilattices is not algebraically coherent, even though it satisfies a strong version of the so-called Smith is Huq condition (on the equivalence of two types of commutators). We also prove that Higgins commutators of normal subobjects are normal, as a consequence of the fact that Heyting semilattices form an arithmetical category. We provide an elementary characterisation of when a pair of subobjects commutes, and use this in the construction of two counterexamples. We further show that centralisers exist, centralisers of normal monomorphisms are normal monomorphisms, and normal monomorphisms are closed under composition. We study the latter condition in detail. On the other hand, we show that the category of Heyting semilattices does not satisfy normality of unions. Hence, it is not action accessible and so it does not admit all normalisers. In particular, this means that the known implication between action accessibility and the condition requiring the existence of centralisers of normal monomorphisms which are themselves normal, is strict.
arXiv comment31 pages
References in corpus (12)
- A note on the "Smith is Huq" condition
- The ternary commutator obstruction for internal crossed modules
- Relative Commutator Theory in Semi-Abelian Categories
- On the normality of Higgins commutators
- A characterisation of Lie algebras amongst anti-commutative algebras
- Higher central extensions and cohomology
- Algebras with representable representations
- Further remarks on the "Smith is Huq" condition
- Peri-abelian categories and the universal central extension condition
- On the "three subobjects lemma" and its higher-order generalisations
- Associativity and the cosmash product in operadic varieties of algebras
- Algebraic logoi