The first phase of mass transfer in low-mass binaries: neither stable nor a common envelope

Abstract

The masses of the white dwarfs in a binary carry information about previous mass-transfer phases. The core mass -- radius relation of low-mass giants gives the size of the progenitor of a helium white dwarf at the moment it last filled its Roche lobe. Previously, we used this information for a few observed systems to propose a new mass-transfer type, based on an angular momentum balance. Our aim is to investigate if stable mass transfer instead of the angular momentum prescription is consistent with the observed double helium white dwarf masses. We reconstruct the progenitor evolution of observed double helium white dwarfs using the core mass -- radius relation and evaluate if the periods at the start of the second phases of mass transfer are consistent with the outcome of stable mass transfer. More generally, we calculate the mass distribution of double helium white dwarfs for three different progenitors scenarios: double common envelope (with parameter $\alpha \lambda$), angular momentum prescription (with parameter $\gamma$) and stable mass transfer. We find that the observed systems are generally not consistent with stable mass transfer. Stable mass transfer leads to a tight correlation between the two white dwarf masses in a binary that is not consistent with the observed mass distribution. Double common envelope evolution is a particularly poor fit to the observations. The angular momentum prescription can populate the observed mass distribution, but not perfectly. We conclude that the first phase of mass transfer initiated on the red giant branch in low-mass systems does not generally proceed as stable mass transfer nor as common envelope, and thus is poorly understood. This may be related to the fact that for many observed binaries that have finished the first phase of mass transfer the orbit is eccentric, which is an unexpected outcome of mass transfer.

arXiv commentAccepted for publication, corrected small error in reference list

References in corpus (45)

• Observational clues to the progenitors of Type-Ia supernovae
• Population synthesis for double white dwarfs I.Close detached systems
• Supernova Type Ia progenitors from merging double white dwarfs: Using a new population synthesis model
• Prospects for detection of detached double white dwarf binaries with Gaia, LSST and LISA
• On the alpha formalism for the common envelope interaction
• Reconstructing the star formation history of the Milky Way disc(s) from chemical abundances
• The LISA Gravitational Wave Foreground: A Study of Double White Dwarfs
• Predicting the LISA white dwarf binary population in the Milky Way with cosmological simulations
• Type Ia Supernova Explosions in Binary Systems: A Review
• LMXB and IMXB Evolution: I. The Binary Radio Pulsar PSR J1614-2230
• A systematic search of Zwicky Transient Facility data for ultracompact binary LISA-detectable gravitational-wave sources
• Optical spectra of the carbon-oxygen accretion discs in the ultra-compact X-ray binaries 4U 0614+09, 4U 1543-624 and 2S 0918-549
• Common Envelope Evolution Redux
• Orbital eccentricities of binary systems with a former AGB star
• Adiabatic mass loss in binary stars. III. From the base of the red giant branch to the tip of asymptotic giant branch
• The ESO supernovae type Ia progenitor survey (SPY)
• The gravitational wave signal from diverse populations of double white dwarf binaries in the Galaxy
• On the Formation of Double White Dwarfs through Stable Mass Transfer and a Common Envelope
• The Discovery of a Short Period Double-Degenerate Binary Star
• Near-Infrared Photometry of Globular Clusters Towards the Galactic Bulge: Observations and Photometric Metallicity Indicators
• Coping with loss: Stability of mass transfer from post-main sequence donor stars
• A detached double degenerate with a 1.4 hr orbital period
• Testing eccentricity pumping mechanisms to model eccentric long period sdB binaries with MESA
• An 8.8 minute orbital period eclipsing detached double white dwarf binary
• Hot subdwarfs in close binaries observed from space I: orbital, atmospheric, and absolute parameters and the nature of their companions
• Precise parameters for both white dwarfs in the eclipsing binary CSS 41177
• White dwarf binaries suggest a common envelope efficiency $\alpha \sim 1/3$
• The mass ratio distribution of short period double degenerate stars
• SDSS J1152+0248: An eclipsing double white dwarf from the Kepler K2 campaign
• The ELM Survey South. II. Two dozen new low mass white dwarf binaries
• The eccentric behaviour of windy binary stars
• A 1201 s Orbital Period Detached Binary: the First Double Helium Core White Dwarf LISA Verification Binary
• A pulsating white dwarf in an eclipsing binary
• Binary evolution along the Red Giant Branch with BINSTAR: The barium star perspective
• Disc-binary interactions in depleted post-AGB binaries
• Asymmetry in the number of L4 and L5 Jupiter Trojans driven by jumping Jupiter
• SCATTER: A New Common Envelope Formalism
• Two new Double-lined Spectroscopic Binary White Dwarfs
• Hot subdwarfs in close binaries observed from space II: Analysis of the light curves
• The White Dwarf Binary Pathways Survey -- IX. Three long period white dwarf plus subgiant binaries
• The Discovery of Two LISA Sources within 0.5 kpc
• An Eclipsing 47 minute Double White Dwarf Binary at 400 pc
• Testing tidal theory using Gaia binaries: the red giant branch
• WD mass and orbital period relation of sdB + He WD binaries
• Consistency Tests for Comparing Astrophysical Models and Observations

Cited by in corpus (3)

• From Main Sequence Binary to Blast: MESA Modeling of the Double-Detonation Progenitor PTF1~J2238+7430
• Formation of Extremely Low-mass White Dwarf Binaries Undergoing Enhanced Angular Momentum Loss
• Two hot pre-white dwarfs inside the red-giant-branch planetary nebula Pa 13 -- Double core evolution or common envelope-induced rejuvenation?