Comment on " Second Law of Thermodynamics without Einstein Relation'', arXiv:2405.17142
arXiv:2503.20810
Abstract
It is argued the the idea of a single temperature-like variable, introduced in [1], which enters a generalized second law for Markovian open system in non-equilibrium environment is not sufficient for a consistent and useful thermodynamic formalism. The origin of the Second Law and ``local temperatures'' in Markovian theory of Quantum Open Systems is revisited and illustrated by simple examples.
3 pages, comment on arXiv:2405.17142