On covariant and canonical Hamiltonian formalisms: Weakly Isolated Horizons

Abstract

The Hamiltonian description of classical gauge theories is a well studied subject. The two best known approaches, namely the covariant and canonical Hamiltonian formalisms have received a lot of attention in the literature. However, in our opinion, a full understanding of the relation between them is not available, specially for gauge theories that are defined over regions with boundaries. Here we consider this issue, for spacetimes with isolated horizons as inner boundaries (representing black holes in equilibrium), and assess whether their corresponding descriptions can be seen as equivalent. First, we shall review and reanalyze both formalisms from anew, focusing on some subtleties not considered before. Next we show that, if we compare them at face value, there are subtle differences between both formalisms, for instance in the derivation of horizon energy, a physical observable of the theory, as well as in the number of boundary degrees of freedom. At first sight, it seems that the canonical formalism introduces some additional ambiguities that make more challenging the comparison between both formalisms. We analyze different possible interpretations in both approaches and show how one can obtain complete correspondence between results within covariant and canonical formalisms. We also show that the correspondence can be achieved in the original phase spaces, with no boundary degrees of freedom, or by appropriately extending them by adding horizon degrees of freedom. Along the way, we shed light on the role of boundary terms in the symplectic structure in relation to boundary degrees of freedom.

26 pages, no figures. Discussion expanded. To match published version in Class. Quant. Grav

References in corpus (9)

• Gravitational action with null boundaries
• Laws of Black Hole Mechanics from Holst Action
• Null Infinity as a Weakly Isolated Horizon
• Covariant canonical formulations of classical field theories
• Proof of the equivalence of the symplectic forms derived from the canonical and the covariant phase space formalisms
• On the on-shell equivalence of general relativity and Holst theories with nonmetricity, torsion, and boundaries
• Weakly Isolated Horizons: First order actions and gauge symmetries
• Weakly Isolated Horizons: $3+1$ decomposition and canonical formulations in self-dual variables
• On covariant and canonical Hamiltonian formalisms for gauge theories