The fundamental difference between logical and thermodynamic irreversibilities, or, Why Landauer's result cannot be a physical principle
arXiv:2409.15085 · doi:10.3390/sym16121594
Abstract
Landauer's "principle" claims that erasing one bit of information necessarily dissipates at least Tln2 of heat into the surroundings, making a possibly logically irreversible operation also thermodynamically irreversible. It is commonly accepted that this result is a fundamental principle of physics that definitively establishes the link between information and energy. Here we show that this result cannot be general. In fact it comes: 1) from a confusion between logical and thermodynamic irreversibilities and between logical and thermodynamic states, which is reminiscent of the classic Gibbs' paradox about the joining of two volumes of the same gas; and 2) from two unnecessary constraints imposed on the erase procedure. Clarifying these points permits: to dissociate the notions of logical and thermodynamic irreversibilities; to invalidate Landauer's result as being a general physical principle; and to open the door to hardware implementations allowing erasure to follow a thermodynamically reversible, or at least quasistatic, path.
References in corpus (10)
- The physics of forgetting: Landauer's erasure principle and information theory
- Finite-time Landauer principle
- Single-atom demonstration of quantum Landauer principle
- Finite-Time Quantum Landauer Principle and Quantum Coherence
- Information and thermodynamics: Experimental verification of Landauer's erasure principle
- Landauer Principle and General Relativity
- Landauer's principle and black hole area quantization
- Three types of Landauer's erasure principle: a microscopic view
- Plea for the use of the exact Stirling formula in statistical mechanics
- On the supposed mass of entropy and that of information