Suggested magnetic braking prescription derived from field complexity fails to reproduce the cataclysmic variable orbital period gap

Abstract

Magnetic wind braking drives the spin-down of low-mass stars and the evolution of most interacting binary stars. A magnetic braking prescription that was claimed to reproduce both the period distribution of cataclysmic variables (CVs) and the evolution of the rotation rates of low-mass stars is based on a relation between the angular momentum loss rate and magnetic field complexity. The magnetic braking model based on field complexity has been claimed to predict a detached phase that could explain the observed period gap in the period distribution of CVs but has never been tested in detailed models of CV evolution. Here we fill this gap. We incorporated the suggested magnetic braking law in MESA and simulated the evolution of CVs for different initial stellar masses and initial orbital periods. We find that the prescription for magnetic braking based on field complexity fails to reproduce observations of CVs. The predicted secondary star radii are smaller than measured, and an extended detached phase that is required to explain the observed period gap (a dearth of non-magnetic CVs with periods between $\sim 2$ and $\sim 3$ hours) is not predicted. Proposed magnetic braking prescriptions based on a relation between the angular momentum loss rate and field complexity are too weak to reproduce the bloating of donor stars in CVs derived from observations and, in contrast to previous claims, do not provide an explanation for the observed period gap. The suggested steep decrease in the angular momentum loss rate does not lead to detachment. Stronger magnetic braking prescriptions and a discontinuity at the fully convective boundary are needed to explain the evolution of close binary stars that contain compact objects. The tension between braking laws derived from the spin-down of single stars and those required to explain CVs and other close binaries containing compact objects remains.

5 pages, 4 figures

References in corpus (26)

• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA)
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Pulsating Variable Stars, Rotation, Convective Boundaries, and Energy Conservation
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Time-Dependent Convection, Energy Conservation, Automatic Differentiation, and Infrastructure
• Updated Electron-Conduction Opacities: The Impact on Low-Mass Stellar Models
• The Mass-Dependence of Angular Momentum Evolution in Sun-Like Stars
• Solar-type dynamo behaviour in fully convective stars without a tachocline
• Coulomb tunneling for fusion reactions in dense matter: Path integral Monte Carlo versus mean field
• Skye: A Differentiable Equation of State
• The origin and evolution of magnetic white dwarfs in close binary stars
• A common origin of magnetism from planets to white dwarfs
• Effective Temperatures of Cataclysmic Variable White Dwarfs as a Probe of their Evolution
• An Observational Study of Tidal Synchronization in Solar-Type Binary Stars in the Open Clusters M35 and M34
• Flare Rates, Rotation Periods. and Spectroscopic Activity Indicators of a Volume-Complete Sample of Mid-to-Late M dwarfs within 15 Parsecs
• The evolutionary status of Cataclysmic Variables: Eclipse modelling of 15 systems
• New insight into the magnetism of degenerate stars from the analysis of a volume limited sample of white dwarfs
• New Conductive Opacities for White Dwarf Envelopes
• Evidence for reduced magnetic braking in polars from binary population models
• The Missing Magnetic Morphology Term in Stellar Rotation Evolution
• A catalogue of cataclysmic variables from 20 years of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey with new classifications, periods, trends and oddities
• Magnetic braking saturates: evidence from the orbital period distribution of low-mass detached eclipsing binaries from ZTF
• The cataclysmic variable orbital period gap: More evident than ever
• Reversing the verdict: Cataclysmic variables could be the dominant progenitors of AM CVn binaries after all
• Period bouncers as detached magnetic cataclysmic variables
• Magnetic dynamos in white dwarfs -- II. Relating magnetism and pollution
• The formation of the magnetic symbiotic star FN Sgr
• Estimating the Convective Turnover Time

Cited by in corpus (2)

• Further evidence of saturated, boosted, and disrupted magnetic braking from evolutionary tracks of cataclysmic variables
• A Mass Transferring Brown Dwarf Binary on a 57 Minute Orbit