Total Solar Eclipse White Light Images as a Benchmark for PFSS Coronal Magnetic Field Models: An In-Depth Analysis over a Solar Cycle

Abstract

Potential Field Source Surface (PFSS) models are widely used to simulate coronal magnetic fields. PFSS models use the observed photospheric magnetic field as the inner boundary condition and assume a perfectly radial field beyond a ``Source Surface" ($R_{ss}$). At present, total solar eclipse (TSE) white light images are the only data that delineate the coronal magnetic field from the photosphere out to several solar radii ($R_{\odot }$). We utilize a complete solar cycle span of these images between 2008 and 2020 as a benchmark to assess the reliability of PFSS models. For a quantitative assessment, we apply a rolling Hough transform (RHT) to the eclipse data and corresponding PFFS models to measure the difference, $\Delta \theta$, between the data and model magnetic field lines throughout the corona. We find that the average $\Delta \theta$, $⟨\Delta \theta ⟩$, can be minimized for a given choice of $R_{ss}$ depending on the phase within a solar cycle. In particular, $R_{ss}\approx 1.3R_{\odot }$ is found to be optimal for solar maximum, while $R_{ss}\approx 3R_{\odot }$ yields a better match at solar minimum. However, large ($⟨\Delta \theta ⟩>10^{\circ }$) discrepancies between TSE data and PFSS-generated coronal field lines remain regardless of the choice of source surface. Yet, implementation of solar cycle dependent $R_{ss}$ optimal values do yield more reliable PFSS-generated coronal field lines for use in models and for tracing in-situ measurements back to their sources at the Sun.

arXiv comment21 pages, 16 figures, accepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (14)

• Alfven Wave Solar Model (AWSoM): Coronal Heating
• Magnetically Aligned HI Fibers and the Rolling Hough Transform
• Magnetic connectivity of the ecliptic plane within 0.5 AU : PFSS modeling of the first PSP encounter
• Coronal Magnetic Field Topology From Total Solar Eclipse Observations
• Reconstructing coronal hole areas with EUHFORIA and adapted WSA model: optimising the model parameters
• The Color and Brightness of the F-Corona Inferred from the 2019 July 2 Total Solar Eclipse
• Evolution of the Alfvén Mach number associated with a coronal mass ejection shock
• Identifying the Coronal Source Regions of Solar Wind Streams from Total Solar Eclipse Observations and in situ Measurements Extending Over a Solar Cycle
• The Solar Minimum Eclipse of 2019 July 2: II. The First Absolute Brightness Measurements and MHD Model Predictions of Fe X, XI and XIV out to 3.4 Rs
• Automated Spatiotemporal Analysis of Fibrils and Coronal Rain using the Rolling Hough Transform
• Validation scheme for solar coronal models -- constraints from multi-perspective observations in EUV and white-light
• The Solar Minimum Eclipse of 2019 July 2. III. Inferring the Coronal $T_e$ with a Radiative Differential Emission Measure Inversion
• The Double-Bubble CME of the 2020 December 14 Total Solar Eclipse
• Evaluation of Coronal and Interplanetary Magnetic Field Extrapolation Using PSP Solar Wind Observation

Cited by in corpus (2)

• Estimating uncertainties in the back-mapping of the fast solar wind
• Proposal of a Novel Physical Parameter Characterizing Solar Wind Speed in a Wave-Driven Model