Disproving a weaker form of Hooley's conjecture

Abstract

Hooley conjectured that $G(x;q)\ll x\log q$, as soon as $q\to +\infty$, where $G(x;q)$ represents the variance of primes $p\le x$ in arithmetic progressions modulo $q$, weighted by $\log p$. In this paper, we study $G_{\eta }(x;q)$, a function similar to $G(x;q)$, but including the weighting factor $\eta \left(\frac{p}{x}\right)$, which has a dampening effect on the values of $G_{\eta }$. Our study is motivated by the disproof of Hooley's conjecture by Fiorilli and Martin in the range $q\asymp \log \log x$. Even though this weighting factor dampens the values, we still prove that an estimation of the form $G_{\eta }(x;q)\ll x\log q$ is false in the same range.