Markovian and non-Markovian master equations versus an exactly solvable model of a qubit in a cavity

Abstract

Quantum master equations are commonly used to model the dynamics of open quantum systems, but their accuracy is rarely compared with the analytical solution of exactly solvable models. In this work, we perform such a comparison for the damped Jaynes-Cummings model of a qubit in a leaky cavity, for which an analytical solution is available in the one-excitation subspace. We consider the non-Markovian time-convolutionless master equation up to the second (Redfield) and fourth orders as well as three types of Markovian master equations: the coarse-grained, cumulant, and standard rotating-wave approximation (RWA) Lindblad equations. We compare the exact solution to these master equations for three different spectral densities: impulse, Ohmic, and triangular. We demonstrate that the coarse-grained master equation outperforms the standard RWA-based Lindblad master equation for weak coupling or high qubit frequency (relative to the spectral density high-frequency cutoff ${\omega }_c$), where the Markovian approximation is valid. In the presence of non-Markovian effects characterized by oscillatory, non-decaying behavior, the TCL approximation closely matches the exact solution for short evolution times (in units of ${\omega }_c^{-1}$) even outside the regime of validity of the Markovian approximations. For long evolution times, all master equations perform poorly, as quantified in terms of the trace-norm distance from the exact solution. The fourth-order time-convolutionless master equation achieves the top performance in all cases. Our results highlight the need for reliable approximation methods to describe open-system quantum dynamics beyond the short-time limit.

28 pages, 9 figures. v2: added new references

References in corpus (32)

• Charge insensitive qubit design derived from the Cooper pair box
• Entanglement and non-Markovianity of quantum evolutions
• Dynamical decoupling and noise spectroscopy with a superconducting flux qubit
• Open Quantum Systems. An Introduction
• Stochastic wave function method for non-Markovian quantum master equations
• Quantum Adiabatic Markovian Master Equations
• Universal Lindblad equation for open quantum systems
• Completely Positive Post-Markovian Master Equation via a Measurement Approach
• Exact master equations for the non-Markovian decay of a qubit
• Robustness of Decoherence-Free Subspaces for Quantum Computation
• Internal Consistency of Fault-Tolerant Quantum Error Correction in Light of Rigorous Derivations of the Quantum Markovian Limit
• Observation of classical-quantum crossover of 1/f flux noise and its paramagnetic temperature dependence
• From Completely Positive Maps to the Quantum Markovian Semigroup Master Equation
• Completely positive master equation for arbitrary driving and small level spacing
• Time Dependent Markovian Quantum Master Equation
• Dynamical Decoupling Using Slow Pulses: Efficient Suppression of 1/f Noise
• Asymptotic Floquet states of open quantum systems: The role of interaction
• Coarse-Graining Can Beat the Rotating Wave Approximation in Quantum Markovian Master Equations
• Quantum simulation of the spin-boson model with a microwave circuit
• Non-Markovian dynamics of a qubit coupled to an Ising spin bath
• Markovian Quantum Master Equation beyond Adiabatic Regime
• Completely Positive, Simple, and Possibly Highly Accurate Approximation of the Redfield Equation
• Non-Markovian dissipative dynamics of two coupled qubits in independent reservoirs: a comparison between exact solutions and master equation approaches
• Predicting non-Markovian superconducting qubit dynamics from tomographic reconstruction
• Completely positive approximate solutions of driven open quantum systems
• Quantum trajectories for time-dependent adiabatic master equations
• Geometric-Arithmetic Master Equation in Large and Fast Open Quantum Systems
• Field-theoretical approach to open quantum systems and the Lindblad equation
• Error Reduction in Quantum Annealing using Boundary Cancellation: Only the End Matters
• Modeling low- and high-frequency noise in transmon qubits with resource-efficient measurement
• Quantum emulation of the transient dynamics in the multistate Landau-Zener model
• An approximation scheme and non-Hermitian re-normalization for description of atom-field system evolution

Cited by in corpus (7)

• Sixth-order time-convolutionless master equation and beyond: Late-time resummations, two types of divergences, and the limits of validity
• Parametric approximation as open quantum systems problem
• Interplay between external driving, dissipation and collective effects in the Markovian and non-Markovian regimes
• Energy-Invariant Catalysis of Stable Ergotropy in Strongly Coupled Spin-Chain Quantum Batteries
• Continuous quantum correction on Markovian and Non-Markovian models
• Expansion of time-convolutionless non-Markovian quantum master equations: A case study using the Fano-Anderson model
• Stabilizing boundary time crystals through Non-markovian dynamics