Knots bounding non-isotopic ribbon disks

Abstract

We exhibit infinitely many ribbon knots, each of which bounds infinitely many pairwise non-isotopic ribbon disks whose exteriors are diffeomorphic. This family provides a positive answer to a stronger version of an old question of Hitt and Sumners. The examples arise from our main result: a classification of fibered, homotopy-ribbon disks for each generalized square knot $T_{p,q}\#{\overline{T}}_{p,q}$ up to isotopy. Precisely, we show that each generalized square knot bounds infinitely many pairwise non-isotopic fibered, homotopy-ribbon disks, all of whose exteriors are diffeomorphic. When $q=2$, we prove further that infinitely many of these disks are also ribbon; whether the disks are always ribbon is an open problem.

15 pages, 6 color figures