Nonexistence of a parent theory for general relativity and unimodular gravity
arXiv:2309.06903 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.109.104004
Abstract
General Relativity (GR) and Unimodular Gravity (UG) provide two equivalent descriptions of gravity that differ in the nature of the cosmological constant. While GR is based on the group of diffeomorphisms that permits the cosmological constant in the action, UG is based on the subgroup of volume-preserving diffeomorphisms together with Weyl transformations which forbid the presence of the cosmological constant. However, the cosmological constant reappears in UG as an integration constant so it arises as a global degree of freedom. Since gauge symmetries are simply redundancies in our description of physical systems, a natural question is whether there exists a "parent theory" with the full diffeomorphisms and Weyl transformations as gauge symmetries so that it reduces to GR and UG respectively by performing suitable (partial) gauge fixings. We will explore this question by introducing Stueckelberg fields both in GR and UG to complete the gauge symmetries in each theory to that of the would-be parent theory. Despite the dynamical equivalence of the two theories, we find that precisely the additional global degree of freedom provided by the cosmological constant in UG obstructs the construction of the parent theory.
arXiv comment29 pages, no figures, no tables; v2: Matches the published version. Some clarifications are added
References in corpus (18)
- Teleparallel Palatini theories
- Transverse Fierz-Pauli symmetry
- The Renormalization Group flow of unimodular f(R) gravity
- On unimodular quantum gravity
- Unimodular Gravity vs General Relativity: A status report
- Dark energy from quantum gravity discreteness
- Unimodular quantum gravity and the cosmological constant
- Gravity with more or less gauging
- A link that matters: Towards phenomenological tests of unimodular asymptotic safety
- Can quantum fluctuations differentiate between standard and unimodular gravity?
- Exploring new corners of asymptotically safe unimodular quantum gravity
- Unimodular Trees versus Einstein Trees
- TDiff and Weyl Invariant Massive Spin-2: Linear Theory
- Non-minimal Tinges of Unimodular Gravity
- Taming higher-derivative interactions and bootstrapping gravity with soft theorems
- Geometrical Trinity of Unimodular Gravity
- Topological Features of the Quantum Vacuum
- Embedding Unimodular Gravity in String Theory