Light-harvesting efficiency cannot depend on optical coherence in the absence of orientational order

Abstract

The coherence of light has been proposed as a quantum-mechanical control for enhancing light-harvesting efficiency. In particular, optical coherence can be manipulated by changing either the polarization state or spectral phase of the light. Here, we show that, in weak light, light-harvesting efficiency cannot be controlled using any form of optical coherence in molecular light-harvesting systems and, more broadly, those comprising orientationally disordered sub-units and operating on longer-than-ultrafast timescales. Under those conditions, optical coherence does not affect light-harvesting efficiency, meaning that it cannot be used for control. Specifically, polarization-state control is lost in disordered samples or when the molecules reorient on the timescales of the light-harvesting, and spectral-phase control is lost when the efficiency is time-averaged for longer than the optical coherence time. In practice, efficiency is always averaged over long times, meaning that coherent optical control is only possible through polarisation in systems with orientational order.

arXiv comment8 + 5 pages, 5 + 1 figures. Replaced previous manuscript with the version accepted by The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters

References in corpus (20)

• Optical clock intercomparison with $6\times 10^{-19}$ precision in one hour
• An efficient biologically-inspired photocell enhanced by quantum coherence
• Exciton Dynamics in Photosynthetic Complexes: Excitation by Coherent and Incoherent Light
• Tailoring the degree of entanglement of two coherently coupled quantum emitters
• Incoherent Excitation of Thermally Equilibrated Open Quantum Systems
• Optimizing co-operative multi-environment dynamics in a dark-state-enhanced photosynthetic heat engine
• Hidden Vibronic and Excitonic Structure and Vibronic Coherence Transfer in the Bacterial Reaction Center
• Photocell Optimisation Using Dark State Protection
• Classification of Coherent Enhancements of Light-Harvesting Processes
• Quantum-enhanced capture of photons using optical ratchet states
• Coherent and controllable enhancement of light-harvesting efficiency
• On thermodynamic inconsistencies in several photosynthetic and solar cell models and how to fix them
• Coherent Phase Control in Closed and Open Quantum Systems: A General Master Equation Approach
• Mechanisms in Environmentally-Assisted One-photon Phase Control
• Optimal power generation using dark states in dimers strongly coupled to their environment
• Environmentally improved coherent light harvesting
• The dark side of energy transport along excitonic wires: On-site energy barriers facilitate efficient, vibrationally-mediated transport through optically dark subspaces
• Coherent excitation energy transfer in model photosynthetic reaction center: Effects of non-Markovian quantum environment
• Quantum Conditions on Dynamics and Control in Open Systems
• The Scaling of Weak Field Phase-Only Control in Markovian Dynamics