Dispersion relations alone cannot guarantee causality

Abstract

We show that linear superpositions of plane waves involving a single-valued, covariantly stable dispersion relation $\omega (k)$ always propagate outside the lightcone, unless $\omega (k)=a+bk$. This implies that there is no notion of causality for individual dispersion relations, since no mathematical condition on the function $\omega (k)$ (such as the front velocity or the asymptotic group velocity conditions) can serve as a sufficient condition for subluminal propagation in dispersive media. Instead, causality can only emerge from a careful cancellation that occurs when one superimposes all the excitation branches of a physical model. This is shown to happen automatically in local theories of matter that are covariantly stable. Hence, we find that the need for nonhydrodynamic modes in relativistic fluid mechanics is analogous to the need for antiparticles in relativistic quantum mechanics.

6 pages (Main Text) + 2 pages (Supplementary Material), published on Physical Review Letters, see https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.132.162301

References in corpus (4)

• Viscosity Bound and Causality Violation
• Stability and Causality in relativistic dissipative hydrodynamics
• When the entropy has no maximum: A new perspective on the instability of the first-order theories of dissipation
• Bounds on transport from hydrodynamic stability

Cited by in corpus (13)

• Theories of Relativistic Dissipative Fluid Dynamics
• The stochastic relativistic advection diffusion equation from the Metropolis algorithm
• Recent developments in mathematical aspects of relativistic fluids
• Consistent inclusion of fluctuations in first-order causal and stable relativistic hydrodynamics
• Convergence of the hydrodynamic gradient expansion in relativistic kinetic theory
• Infinite Order Hydrodynamics: An Analytical Example
• Transport coefficients of transient hydrodynamics for the hadron-resonance gas and thermal-mass quasiparticle models
• Analytic solutions for the linearized first-order magnetohydrodynamics and implications for causality and stability
• Dispersion relations of relativistic radiation hydrodynamics
• Causality constraints on radiative transfer
• How Lorentz boosts reshape relaxation spectra
• Acausality-driven instabilities in transient relativistic viscous hydrodynamics
• The diffusion equation is compatible with special relativity