A comparative study of resistivity models for simulations of magnetic reconnection in the solar atmosphere

Abstract

Magnetic reconnection is a fundamental mechanism in astrophysics. A common challenge in mimicking this process numerically in particular for the Sun is that the solar electrical resistivity is small compared to the diffusive effects caused by the discrete nature of codes. We aim to study different anomalous resistivity models and their respective effects on simulations related to magnetic reconnection in the Sun. We used the Bifrost code to perform a 2D numerical reconnection experiment in the corona that is driven by converging opposite polarities at the solar surface. This experiment was run with three different commonly used resistivity models: 1) the hyper-diffusion model originally implemented in Bifrost, 2) a resistivity proportional to the current density, and 3) a resistivity proportional to the square of the electron drift velocity. The study was complemented with a 1D experiment of a Harris current sheet with the same resistivity models. The 2D experiment shows that the three resistivity models are capable of producing results in satisfactory agreement with each other in terms of the current sheet length, inflow velocity, and Poynting influx. Even though Petschek-like reconnection occurred with the current density-proportional resistivity while the other two cases mainly followed plasmoid-mediated reconnection, the large-scale evolution of thermodynamical quantities such as temperature and density are quite similar between the three cases. For the 1D experiment, some recalibration of the diffusion parameters is needed to obtain comparable results. Specifically the hyper-diffusion and the drift velocity-dependent resistivity model needed only minor adjustments, while the current density-proportional model needed a rescaling of several orders of magnitude.

arXiv comment15 pages, 8 figures, 1 movie

References in corpus (31)

• The stellar atmosphere simulation code Bifrost
• Numerical simulations of quiet Sun magnetism: On the contribution from a small-scale dynamo
• Extension of the MURaM radiative MHD code for coronal simulations
• Giant Chromospheric Anemone Jet Observed with Hinode and Comparison with Magnetohydrodynamic Simulations: Evidence of Propagating Alfven Waves and Magnetic Reconnection
• Plasma Jets and Eruptions in Solar Coronal Holes: a 3D flux emergence experiment
• Bombs and flares at the surface and lower atmosphere of the Sun
• A simple model for magnetic reconnection heated corona
• Magneto-acoustic waves in sunspots: first results from a new 3D nonlinear magnetohydrodynamic code
• Three-Dimensional Simulations of Tearing and Intermittency in Coronal Jets
• Ellerman bombs and UV bursts: transient events in chromospheric current sheets
• Reconnection-Driven Energy Cascade in Magnetohydrodynamic Turbulence
• Onset of Fast Reconnection in Hall Magnetohydrodynamics Mediated by the Plasmoid Instability
• Rotating Solar Jets in Simulations of Flux Emergence with Thermal Conduction
• The cool surge following flux emergence in a radiation-MHD experiment
• Surges and Si IV bursts in the solar atmosphere. Understanding IRIS and SST observations through RMHD experiments
• Reconnection-Driven Coronal-Hole Jets with Gravity and Solar Wind
• Simulations of small-scale explosive events on the Sun
• Simulating Ellerman bomb-like event
• Light Bridge in a Developing Active Region. II. Numerical Simulation of Flux Emergence and Light Bridge Formation
• Chromospheric Extension of the MURaM Code
• Plasmoid-mediated reconnection in solar UV bursts
• The formation and evolution of reconnection-driven slow-mode shocks in a partially ionised plasma
• A Cancellation Nanoflare Model for Solar Chromospheric and Coronal Heating II. 2D Theory and Simulations
• A Magnetic Reconnection model for Hot Explosions in the Cool Atmosphere of the Sun
• A 2D Model for Coronal Bright Points: Association with Spicules, UV bursts, Surges and EUV Coronal Jets
• Large-amplitude prominence oscillations following the impact by a coronal jet
• Coalescence Instability in Chromospheric Partially Ionised Plasmas
• Eruption of a Magnetic Flux Rope in a Comprehensive Radiative Magnetohydrodynamic Simulation of flare-productive active regions
• Plausibility of ultraviolet burst generation in the low solar chromosphere
• Multi-Fluid Simulations of Upper Chromospheric Magnetic Reconnection with Helium-Hydrogen mixture
• Onset of 2D magnetic reconnection in the solar photosphere, chromosphere and corona

Cited by in corpus (5)

• Deciphering the solar coronal heating: Energizing small-scale loops through surface convection
• A comparative study of resistivity models for simulations of magnetic reconnection in the solar atmosphere. II. Plasmoid formation
• Thin coronal jets and plasmoid-mediated reconnection: Insights from Solar Orbiter observations and Bifrost simulations
• Chromosphere of the quiet sun -- I. Shock and current-sheet dynamics and heating
• Test particle sampling and particle acceleration in a 2D coronal plasmoid-mediated reconnecting current sheet