A critical comparison of general-purpose collective variables for crystal nucleation

Abstract

The nucleation of crystals is a prominent phenomenon in science and technology that still lacks a full atomic-scale understanding. Much work has been devoted to identifying order parameters able to track the process, from the inception of early nuclei to their maturing to critical size until growth of an extended crystal. We critically assess and compare two powerful distance-based collective variables, an effective entropy derived from liquid state theory and the path variable based on permutation invariant vectors using the Kob-Andersen binary mixture and a combination of enhanced-sampling techniques. Our findings reveal a comparable ability to drive nucleation when a bias potential is applied, and comparable free-energy barriers and structural features. Yet, we also found an imperfect correlation with the committor probability on the barrier top which was bypassed by changing the order parameter definition.

References in corpus (25)

• Escaping free-energy minima
• PLUMED 2: New feathers for an old bird
• Testing Mode-Coupling Theory for a Supercooled Binary Lennard-Jones Mixture I: The van Hove Correlation Function
• Accurate determination of crystal structures based on averaged local bond order parameters
• Crystal Nucleation in Liquids: Open Questions and Future Challenges in Molecular Dynamics Simulations
• Molecular enhanced sampling with autoencoders: On-the-fly collective variable discovery and accelerated free energy landscape exploration
• Data-Driven Collective Variables for Enhanced Sampling
• Theoretical evidence for a dense fluid precursor to crystallization
• Entropy based fingerprint for local crystalline order
• Predicting polymorphism in molecular crystals using orientational entropy
• Enhancing entropy and enthalpy fluctuations to drive crystallization in atomistic simulations
• Neural network based path collective variables for enhanced sampling of phase transformations
• Homogeneous nucleation of ice
• Homogeneous and heterogeneous nucleation of Lennard-Jones liquids
• Navigating at Will on the Water Phase Diagram
• Phase diagram of Kob-Andersen type binary Lennard-Jones mixtures
• Pathways to self-organization: crystallization via nucleation and growth
• Non-Equilibrium Phase Transition in an Atomistic Glassformer: the Connection to Thermodynamics
• The nature of geometric frustration in the Kob-Andersen mixture
• Crystallisation Instability in Glassforming Mixtures
• Can Ordered Precursors Promote the Nucleation of Solid Solutions?
• Identification of a Multi-Dimensional Reaction Coordinate for Crystal Nucleation in ${\text{Ni}}_3\text{Al}$
• Interplay between crystallization and glass transition in binary Lennard-Jones mixtures
• Composition dependence of the glass forming ability in binary mixtures: The role of demixing entropy
• Out-of-equilibrium Polymorph Selection in Nanoparticle Freezing