Inevitability of knowing less than nothing
arXiv:2208.14424 · doi:10.22331/q-2024-11-20-1529
Abstract
A colloquial interpretation of entropy is that it is the knowledge gained upon learning the outcome of a random experiment. Conditional entropy is then interpreted as the knowledge gained upon learning the outcome of one random experiment after learning the outcome of another, possibly statistically dependent, random experiment. In the classical world, entropy and conditional entropy take only non-negative values, consistent with the intuition that one has regarding the aforementioned interpretations. However, for certain entangled states, one obtains negative values when evaluating commonly accepted and information-theoretically justified formulas for the quantum conditional entropy, leading to the confounding conclusion that one can know less than nothing in the quantum world. Here, we introduce a physically motivated framework for defining quantum conditional entropy, based on two simple postulates inspired by the second law of thermodynamics (non-decrease of entropy) and extensivity of entropy, and we argue that all plausible definitions of quantum conditional entropy should respect these two postulates. We then prove that all plausible quantum conditional entropies take on negative values for certain entangled states, so that it is inevitable that one can know less than nothing in the quantum world. All of our arguments are based on constructions of physical processes that respect the first postulate, the one inspired by the second law of thermodynamics.
v3: final version accepted for publication in Quantum Journal
References in corpus (34)
- Quantum Resource Theories
- The Uncertainty Principle in the Presence of Quantum Memory
- On quantum Renyi entropies: a new generalization and some properties
- The second laws of quantum thermodynamics
- The operational meaning of min- and max-entropy
- The Physics and Mathematics of the Second Law of Thermodynamics
- Quantum information can be negative
- Strong converse for the classical capacity of entanglement-breaking and Hadamard channels via a sandwiched Renyi relative entropy
- Min- and Max- Relative Entropies and a New Entanglement Monotone
- From Classical to Quantum Shannon Theory
- Negative entropy and information in quantum mechanics
- The thermodynamic meaning of negative entropy
- Security in Quantum Cryptography
- A Fully Quantum Asymptotic Equipartition Property
- Quantum state merging and negative information
- Sandwiched Rényi Divergence Satisfies Data Processing Inequality
- Reversible transformations from pure to mixed states, and the unique measure of information
- Causal and localizable quantum operations
- Information as a resource in distributed quantum systems
- alpha-z-relative Renyi entropies
- Comparison of Quantum Channels by Superchannels
- On the strong converses for the quantum channel capacity theorems
- Fundamental bound on the reliability of quantum information transmission
- Semicausal operations are semilocalizable
- Correlation Detection and an Operational Interpretation of the Renyi Mutual Information
- Relating different quantum generalizations of the conditional Renyi entropy
- On quantum non-signalling boxes
- Sampling of min-entropy relative to quantum knowledge
- Entropy and relative entropy from information-theoretic principles
- The Conditional Uncertainty Principle
- Optimal Extensions of Resource Measures and their Applications
- A-unital Operations and Quantum Conditional Entropy
- Symmetric distinguishability as a quantum resource
- What is Entropy? A new perspective from games of chance