Evaluation of Photos Monte Carlo ambiguities in case of four fermion final states

Abstract

With the increasing precision requirements and growing spectrum of applications of Monte Carlo simulations the evaluation of different components of such simulations and their systematic ambiguities become of utmost interest. In the following, we will address the question of systematic errors for Photos Monte Carlo for simulation of bremsstrahlung corrections in final states, which can not, in principle, be identified as a decay of resonances. It is possible, because the program features explicit and exact parametrization of phase space for multi-body plus multi-photon final states. The Photos emission kernel for some processes consist of complete matrix element, in the remaining cases appropriate approximation is used. Comparisons with results of simulations, from generators based on exact phase space and exact fixed order matrix elements, can be used. For the purpose of such validations Photos provides an option to restrict emissions to single photon only. In the current work we concentrate on final state bremsstrahlung in $q\bar{q}(e^{+}{e}^{-})\to l^{+}{l}^{-}{l}^{+}{l}^{-}\gamma$ and $\gamma \gamma \to l^{+}{l}^{-}\gamma$ processes. The reference distributions used as a cross-check are obtained from the fixed-order MadGraph Monte Carlo simulations. For the purpose of validation we concentrate on those phase space regions where Photos is not expected to work on the basis of its design alone. These phase space regions of hard, non-collinear photons, do not contribute to large logarithmic terms. We find that in these phase space regions the differences between Photos and MadGraph results do not surpass a few percent and these regions, in turn, contribute about 10% to the observed process rates. This is encouraging in view of the possible ambiguities for precise calculation of realistic observables.

arXiv comment24 pages, 8 figures plus additional figures in appendices. Updated to match published version

References in corpus (17)

• The automated computation of tree-level and next-to-leading order differential cross sections, and their matching to parton shower simulations
• A general framework for implementing NLO calculations in shower Monte Carlo programs: the POWHEG BOX
• The Precision Monte Carlo Event Generator KK For Two-Fermion Final States In e+e- Collisions
• PHOTOS Monte Carlo: a precision tool for QED corrections in Z and W decays
• Vector boson pair production at the LHC
• W+W-, WZ and ZZ production in the POWHEG BOX
• Neutral current Drell-Yan with combined QCD and electroweak corrections in the POWHEG BOX
• Precision phenomenology with MCFM
• Precise Higgs-background predictions: merging NLO QCD and squared quark-loop corrections to four-lepton + 0,1 jet production
• Exact $O(\alpha )$ Gauge Invariant YFS Exponentiated Monte Carlo for (Un)Stable for (Un)Stable $W^{+}{W}^{-}$ Production At and Beyond LEP2 Energies
• Next to Leading Logarithms and the PHOTOS Monte Carlo
• Scalar QED, NLO and PHOTOS Monte Carlo
• The Monte Carlo Program KKMC for the Lepton or Quark Pair Production at LEP/SLC Energies -- updates of electroweak calculations
• Matching NLO parton shower matrix element with exact phase space: case of W -> l nu (gamma) and gamma^* -> pi^+pi^-(gamma)
• MC-TESTER v. 1.23: a universal tool for comparisons of Monte Carlo predictions for particle decays in high energy physics
• Four lepton production and the accuracy of QED FSR
• Extra lepton pair emission corrections to Drell-Yan processes in PHOTOS and SANC