DMC-ICE13: ambient and high pressure polymorphs of ice from Diffusion Monte Carlo and Density Functional Theory

Abstract

Ice is one of the most important and interesting molecular crystals exhibiting a rich and evolving phase diagram. Recent discoveries mean that there are now twenty distinct polymorphs; a structural diversity that arises from a delicate interplay of hydrogen bonding and van der Waals dispersion forces. This wealth of structures provides a stern test of electronic structure theories, with Density Functional Theory (DFT) often not able to accurately characterise the relative energies of the various ice polymorphs. Thanks to recent advances that enable the accurate and efficient treatment of molecular crystals with Diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC), we present here the DMC-ICE13 dataset; a dataset of lattice energies of 13 ice polymorphs. This dataset encompasses the full structural complexity found in the ambient and high-pressure molecular ice polymorphs and when experimental reference energies are available our DMC results deliver sub-chemical accuracy. Using this dataset we then perform an extensive benchmark of a broad range of DFT functionals. Of the functionals considered, we find revPBE-D3 and RSCAN to reproduce reference absolute lattice energies with the smallest error, whilst optB86b-vdW and SCAN+rVV10 have the best performance on the relative lattice energies. Our results suggest that a single functional achieving reliable performance for all phases is still missing, and that care is needed in the selection of the most appropriate functional for the desired application. The insights obtained here may also be relevant to liquid water and other hydrogen bonded and dispersion bonded molecular crystals.

References in corpus (29)

• Van der Waals Density Functional for General Geometries
• Van der Waals density functionals applied to solids
• A Higher-Accuracy van der Waals Density Functional
• Perspective: How good is DFT for water?
• Long-range correlation energy calculated from coupled atomic response functions
• SCAN+rVV10: A promising van der Waals density functional
• Ab initio theory and modeling of water
• Twist-averaged Boundary Conditions in Continuum Quantum Monte Carlo
• The Phase Diagram of a Deep Potential Water Model
• Regularized SCAN functional
• Ice XV: a new thermodynamically stable phase of ice
• Hydrogen bonds and van der Waals forces in ice at ambient and high pressures
• Advances in the experimental exploration of water's phase diagram
• Norm-conserving Hartree-Fock pseudopotentials and their asymptotic behavior
• An efficient localized basis set for quantum Monte Carlo calculations on condensed matter
• Variational and Diffusion Quantum Monte Carlo Calculations with the CASINO Code
• On the Accuracy of van der Waals Inclusive Density-Functional Theory Exchange-Correlation Functionals for Ice at Ambient and High Pressures
• Finite size errors in quantum many-body simulations of extended systems
• Phase equilibrium of water with hexagonal and cubic ice using the SCAN functional
• Fast and accurate quantum Monte Carlo for molecular crystals
• Boosting the accuracy and speed of quantum Monte Carlo: size-consistency and time-step
• Energy benchmarks for water clusters and ice structures from an embedded many-body expansion
• Quantum-mechanical exploration of the phase diagram of water
• Interaction between water and carbon nanostructures: How good are current density functional approximations?
• Inexpensive modelling of quantum dynamics using path integral generalized Langevin equation thermostats
• The random phase approximation applied to ice
• The phase diagram of water from quantum simulations
• A new scheme for fixed node diffusion quantum Monte Carlo with pseudopotentials: improving reproducibility and reducing the trial-wave-function bias
• Random phase approximation with exchange for an accurate description of crystalline polymorphism

Cited by in corpus (10)

• How accurate are simulations and experiments for the lattice energies of molecular crystals?
• Hybrid Classical/Machine-Learning Force Fields for the Accurate Description of Molecular Condensed-Phase Systems
• Another Angle on Benchmarking Noncovalent Interactions
• Accurate and efficient machine learning interatomic potentials for finite temperature modeling of molecular crystals
• Systematic discrepancies between reference methods for non-covalent interactions within the S66 dataset
• Reproducibility of fixed-node diffusion Monte Carlo across diverse community codes: The case of water-methane dimer
• On the increase of the melting temperature of water confined in one-dimensional nano-cavities
• Quantum Anharmonic Effects in Hydrogen-Bond Symmetrization of High-Pressure Ice
• Rapidly convergent quantum Monte Carlo using a Chebyshev projector
• Consistent GMTKN55 and molecular-crystal accuracy using minimally empirical DFT with XDM(Z) dispersion