Intersecting near-optimal spaces: European power systems with more resilience to weather variability

Abstract

We suggest a new methodology for designing robust energy systems. For this, we investigate so-called near-optimal solutions to energy system optimisation models; solutions whose objective values deviate only marginally from the optimum. Using a refined method for obtaining explicit geometric descriptions of these near-optimal feasible spaces, we find designs that are as robust as possible to perturbations. This contributes to the ongoing debate on how to define and work with robustness in energy systems modelling. We apply our methods in an investigation using multiple decades of weather data. For the first time, we run a capacity expansion model of the European power system (one node per country) with a 3-hourly temporal resolution with 41 years of weather data. While an optimisation with 41 weather years is at the limits of computational feasibility, we use the near-optimal feasible spaces of single years to gain an understanding of the design space over the full time period. Specifically, we intersect all near-optimal feasible spaces for the individual years in order to get designs that are likely to be feasible over the entire time period. We find significant potential for investment flexibility, and verify the feasibility of these designs by simulating the resulting dispatch problem with four decades of weather data. They are characterised by a shift towards more onshore wind and solar power, while emitting up to 50% less $C{O}_2$ than a cost-optimal solution over that period. Our work builds on recent developments in the field, including techniques such as Modelling to Generate Alternatives and Modelling All Alternatives, and provides new insights into the geometry of near-optimal feasible spaces and the importance of multi-decade weather variability for energy systems design. We also provide an effective way of working with a multi-decade time frame in a highly parallelised manner.

34 pages, 18 figures, 2 tables

References in corpus (3)

• PyPSA: Python for Power System Analysis
• Overcoming the disconnect between energy system and climate modeling
• A validated high-resolution hydro power time-series model for energy systems analysis

Cited by in corpus (15)

• Designing a sector-coupled European energy system robust to 60 years of historical weather data
• Using power system modelling outputs to identify weather-induced extreme events in highly renewable systems
• What is redundant and what is not? Computational trade-offs in modelling to generate alternatives for energy infrastructure deployment
• Little to lose: the case for a robust European green hydrogen strategy
• Trading off regional and overall energy system design flexibility in the net-zero transition
• Stabilized Benders decomposition for energy planning under climate uncertainty
• Inverse methods: How feasible are spatially low-resolved capacity expansion modelling results when disaggregated at high spatial resolution?
• Measuring Exploration: Review and Systematic Evaluation of Modelling to Generate Alternatives Methods in Macro-Energy Systems Planning Models
• The Climatological Renewable Energy Deviation Index (CREDI)
• Spatio-temporal smoothing and dynamics of different electricity flexibility options for highly renewable energy systems -- Case study for Norway
• The effects of fair allocation principles on energy system model designs
• Multi-threshold time series analysis enables characterization of variable renewable energy droughts in Europe
• Exploring near-optimal energy systems with stakeholders: a novel approach for participatory modelling
• Balancing Act: The Cost of Wind Restrictions in Norway's Electricity Transition
• Resilience metrics to guide back-up investments in the power system during extreme weather