A comparison of particle and fluid models for positive streamer discharges in air

Abstract

Both fluid and particle models are commonly used to simulate streamer discharges. In this paper, we quantitatively study the agreement between these approaches for axisymmetric and 3D simulations of positive streamers in air. We use a drift-diffusion-reaction fluid model with the local field approximation and a PIC-MCC (particle-in-cell, Monte Carlo collision) particle model. The simulations are performed at 300 K and 1 bar in a 10 mm plate-plate gap with a 2 mm needle electrode. Applied voltages between 11.7 and 15.6 kV are used, which correspond to background fields of about 15 to 20 kV/cm. Streamer properties like maximal electric field, head position and velocity are compared as a function of time or space. Our results show good agreement between the particle and fluid simulations, in contrast to some earlier comparisons that were carried out in 1D or for negative streamers. To quantify discrepancies between the models, we mainly look at streamer velocities as a function of streamer length. For the test cases considered here, the mean deviation in streamer velocity between the particle and fluid simulations is less than 4%. We study the effect of different types of transport data for the fluid model, and find that flux coefficients lead to good agreement whereas bulk coefficients do not. Furthermore, we find that with a two-term Boltzmann solver, data should be computed using a temporal growth model for the best agreement. The numerical convergence of the particle and fluid models is also studied. In fluid simulations the streamer velocity increases somewhat using finer grids, whereas the particle simulations are less sensitive to the grid. Photoionization is the dominant source of stochastic fluctuations in our simulations. When the same stochastic photoionization model is used, particle and fluid simulations exhibit similar fluctuations.

References in corpus (9)

• The physics of streamer discharge phenomena
• Photoionization in negative streamers: fast computations and two propagation modes
• Review of recent results on streamer discharges and discussion of their relevance for sprites and lightning
• Probing photo-ionization: simulations of positive streamers in varying N2:O2 mixtures
• Simulating streamer discharges in 3D with the parallel adaptive Afivo framework
• A comparison of 3D particle, fluid and hybrid simulations for negative streamers
• The effect of the stochasticity of photoionization on 3D streamer simulations
• How pulse polarity and photoionization control streamer discharge development in long air gaps
• Comparing simulations and experiments of positive streamers in air: steps toward model validation

Cited by in corpus (10)

• Quantitative modeling of streamer discharge branching in air
• A computational study of steady and stagnating positive streamers in N2-O2 mixtures
• A computational study of accelerating, steady and fading negative streamers in ambient air
• Investigation of positive streamers in CO${}_2$: experiments and 3D particle-in-cell simulations
• Double-pulse streamer simulations for varying interpulse times in air
• Estimating the properties of single positive air streamers from measurable parameters
• 3D particle-in-cell simulations of negative and positive streamers in C4F7N-CO2 mixtures
• Microscopic characteristics of SF6 partial discharge induced by a floating linear metal particle
• Calculating radio emissions of positive streamer phenomena using 3D simulations
• 3D particle simulations of positive air-methane streamers for combustion