Full versus quasi-particle self consistency in vertex corrected GW approaches

Abstract

Using seven semiconductors/insulators with band gaps covering the range from 1 eV to 10 eV we systematically explore the performance of two different variants of self-consistency associated with famous Hedin's system of equations: the full self-consistency and the so called quasi-particle approximation to it. The pros and cons of these two variants of self-consistency are sufficiently well documented in literature for the simplest GW approximation to the Hedin's equations. Our study, therefore, aims primarily at the level of theory beyond GW approximation, i.e. at the level of theory which includes vertex corrections. Whereas quasi-particle self-consistency has certain advantages at GW level (well known fact), the situation becomes quite different when vertex corrections are included. In the variant with full self-consistency, vertex corrections (both for polarizability and for self energy) systematically reduce the calculated band gaps making them closer to the experimental values. In the variant with quasi-particle self-consistency, however, an inclusion of the same diagrams has considerably larger effect and calculated band gaps become severely underestimated. Different effect of vertex corrections in two variants of self-consistency can be related to the Z-factor cancellation which plays positive role in quasi-particle self-consistency at GW level of theory but appears to be destructive for the quasi-particle approximation when higher order diagrams are included. Second result of our study is that we were able to reproduce the results obtained with the Questaal code using our FlapwMBPT code when the same variant of self-consistency (quasi-particle) and the same level of vertex corrections (for polarizability only, static approximation for screened interaction, and Tamm-Dancoff approximation for the Bethe-Salpeter equation) are used.

arXiv comment10 pages, 7 figures

References in corpus (32)

• BerkeleyGW: A Massively Parallel Computer Package for the Calculation of the Quasiparticle and Optical Properties of Materials and Nanostructures
• Ab initio calculation of excitonic effects in the optical spectra of semiconductors
• Frequency-dependent local interactions and low-energy effective models from electronic structure calculations
• Resolution-of-identity approach to Hartree-Fock, hybrid density functionals, RPA, MP2, and \textit{GW} with numeric atom-centered orbital basis functions
• Quasiparticle self-consistent $GW$ method; a basis for the independent-particle approximation
• First principles approach to the electronic structure of strongly correlated systems: combining GW and DMFT
• Electron-Phonon Interaction in Tetrahedral Semiconductors
• Band convergence and linearization error correction of all-electron GW calculations: The extreme case of zinc oxide
• All-electron GW approximation with the mixed basis expansion based on the full-potential LMTO method
• Efficient $\mathcal{O}(N^2)$ approach to solve the Bethe-Salpeter equation for excitonic bound states
• Exciton-plasmon states in nanoscale materials: breakdown of the Tamm-Dancoff approximation
• Electronic structure of Pu and Am metals by self consistent relativistic GW
• Comparing electron-phonon coupling strength in diamond, silicon and silicon carbide: First-principles study
• Electronic structure of Na, K, Si, and LiF from self-consistent solution of Hedin's equations including vertex corrections
• Accurate all-electron $G_0{W}_0$ quasiparticle energies employing the full-potential augmented planewave method
• Beyond the quasiparticle approximation: Fully self-consistent $GW$ calculations
• Elimination of the linearization error in GW calculations based on the linearized augmented-plane-wave method
• Correlation effects on electron-phonon coupling in semiconductors: many-body theory along thermal lines
• Self-consistent solution of Hedin's equations: semiconductors/insulators
• Linearized self-consistent quasiparticle GW method: Application to semiconductors and simple metals
• Electron-magnon scattering in elementary ferromagnets from first principles: lifetime broadening and band anomalies
• ComDMFT: a Massively Parallel Computer Package for the Electronic Structure of Correlated-Electron Systems
• Electronic Structure of Chromium Trihalides beyond Density Functional Theory
• Optical response and band structure of LiCoO2 including electron-hole interaction effects
• Theory of temperature dependent phonon-renormalized properties
• Elimination of the linearization error in APW/LAPW basis set: Dirac-Kohn-Sham equations
• One-electron spectra and susceptibilities of 3D electron gas from self-consistent solutions of Hedin's equations
• QSGW: Quasiparticle Self consistent GW with ladder diagrams in W
• Electronic structure of LaNiO${}_2$ and CaCuO${}_2$ from self consistent vertex corrected GW approach
• Electronic structure of van der Waals ferromagnet CrI${}_3$ from self consistent vertex corrected GW approaches
• Spatial non-locality of electronic correlations beyond GW approximation
• Full self-consistency versus quasiparticle self-consistency in diagrammatic approaches: Exactly solvable two-site Hubbard Model

Cited by in corpus (12)

• QS$G\hat{W}$: Quasiparticle Self consistent $GW$ with ladder diagrams in $W$
• An Optimally-Tuned Starting Point for Single-Shot $GW$ Calculations of Solids
• Exploring the Statically Screened $G3W2$ Correction to the $GW$ Self-Energy: Charged Excitations and Total Energies of Finite Systems
• Beyond quasi-particle self-consistent $GW$ for molecules with vertex corrections
• Finite-size Effects in periodic EOM-CCSD for Ionization Energies and Electron Affinities: Convergence Rate and Extrapolation to the Thermodynamic Limit
• Quasiparticle and fully self-consistent GW methods: an unbiased analysis using Gaussian orbitals
• Many-body perturbation theory vs. density functional theory: A systematic benchmark for band gaps of solids
• Many-body perturbation theory for moiré systems
• Joint Approximate Diagonalization approach to Quasiparticle Self-Consistent $GW$ calculations
• Diagrammatic theory of the irreducible coupled-cluster self-energy
• Many body theory beyond GW : towards a complete description of 2-body correlated propagation
• All-electron Quasiparticle Self-consistent GW for Molecules and Periodic Systems within the Numerical Atomic Orbital Framework