Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking for Extreme Vorticity and Strain in the 3D Navier-Stokes Equations

Abstract

We investigate the spatio-temporal structure of the most likely configurations realising extremely high vorticity or strain in the stochastically forced 3D incompressible Navier-Stokes equations. Most likely configurations are computed by numerically finding the highest probability velocity field realising an extreme constraint as solution of a large optimisation problem. High-vorticity configurations are identified as pinched vortex filaments with swirl, while high-strain configurations correspond to counter-rotating vortex rings. We additionally observe that the most likely configurations for vorticity and strain spontaneously break their rotational symmetry for extremely high observable values. Instanton calculus and large deviation theory allow us to show that these maximum likelihood realisations determine the tail probabilities of the observed quantities. In particular, we are able to demonstrate that artificially enforcing rotational symmetry for large strain configurations leads to a severe underestimate of their probability, as it is dominated in likelihood by an exponentially more likely symmetry broken vortex-sheet configuration.

arXiv comment34 pages, 5 figures

References in corpus (28)

• The large deviation approach to statistical mechanics
• PyCUDA and PyOpenCL: A Scripting-Based Approach to GPU Run-Time Code Generation
• Asymptotic Exponents from Low-Reynolds-Number Flows
• Extreme velocity gradients in turbulent flows
• Intermittency of Burgers' Turbulence
• Viscous Instanton for Burgers' Turbulence
• Numerical computation of rare events via large deviation theory
• The instanton method and its numerical implementation in fluid mechanics
• Large Deviations of Surface Height in the Kardar-Parisi-Zhang Equation
• Pressure Hessian and viscous contributions to velocity gradient statistics based on Gaussian random fields
• Large negative velocity gradients in Burgers turbulence
• Dynamical phase transition in large deviation statistics of the Kardar-Parisi-Zhang equation
• Fast simulation of Gaussian random fields
• Instanton filtering for the stochastic Burgers equation
• Extreme event probability estimation using PDE-constrained optimization and large deviation theory, with application to tsunamis
• Multiscale velocity correlations in turbulence and Burgers turbulence: Fusion rules, Markov processes in scale, and multifractal predictions
• Vorticity statistics in the direct cascade of two-dimensional turbulence
• Relevance of instantons in Burgers turbulence
• Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking for Extreme Vorticity and Strain in the 3D Navier-Stokes Equations
• Numerical study of extreme mechanical force exerted by a turbulent flow on a bluff body by direct and rare-event sampling techniques
• Gel'fand-Yaglom type equations for calculating fluctuations around Instantons in stochastic systems
• Instantons for rare events in heavy-tailed distributions
• Multiscale velocity correlation in turbulence: experiments, numerical simulations, synthetic signals
• Efficient Computation of Instantons for Multi-Dimensional Turbulent Flows with Large Scale Forcing
• Confined Vortex Surface and Irreversibility. 1. Properties of Exact solution
• Gaussian Vortex Approximation to the Instanton Equations of two-dimensional Turbulence
• Scaling of locally averaged energy dissipation and enstrophy density in isotropic turbulence
• Stability of tangential discontinuity for the vortex pancakes

Cited by in corpus (11)

• Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking for Extreme Vorticity and Strain in the 3D Navier-Stokes Equations
• Symmetries and zero modes in sample path large deviations
• Scalable Methods for Computing Sharp Extreme Event Probabilities in Infinite-Dimensional Stochastic Systems
• Eddy-Viscous Modeling and the Topology of Extreme Circulation Events in Three-Dimensional Turbulence
• Short-time large deviations of the spatially averaged height of a KPZ interface on a ring
• Twisting vortex lines regularize Navier-Stokes turbulence
• Extreme events and instantons in Lagrangian passive scalar turbulence models
• Schrödinger Equation Driven by the Square of a Gaussian Field: Instanton Analysis in the Large Amplification Limit
• Instantons, fluctuations and singularities in the supercritical stochastic nonlinear Schroedinger equation
• Synthetic Turbulence via an Instanton Gas Approximation
• From the Rose-DuBois Ansatz of Hot Spot Fields to the Instanton Solution: a Pedestrian Presentation