A quantitative comparison of amplitude versus intensity interferometry for astronomy
arXiv:2106.05640 · doi:10.1088/1367-2630/ac5f30
Abstract
Astronomical imaging can be broadly classified into two types. The first type is amplitude interferometry, which includes conventional optical telescopes and Very Large Baseline Interferometry (VLBI). The second type is intensity interferometry, which relies on Hanbury Brown and Twiss-type measurements. At optical frequencies, where direct phase measurements are impossible, amplitude interferometry has an effective numerical aperture that is limited by the distance from which photons can coherently interfere. Intensity interferometry, on the other hand, correlates only photon fluxes and can thus support much larger numerical apertures, but suffers from a reduced signal due to the low average photon number per mode in thermal light. It has hitherto not been clear which method is superior under realistic conditions. Here, we give a comparative analysis of the performance of amplitude and intensity interferometry, and we relate this to the fundamental resolution limit that can be achieved in any physical measurement. Using the benchmark problem of determining the separation between two distant thermal point sources, e.g., two adjacent stars, we give a short tutorial on optimal estimation theory and apply it to stellar interferometry. We find that for very small angular separations the large baseline achievable in intensity interferometry can more than compensate for the reduced signal strength. We also explore options for practical implementations of Very Large Baseline Intensity Interferometry (VLBII).
References in corpus (42)
- First M87 Event Horizon Telescope Results. I. The Shadow of the Supermassive Black Hole
- The SIMBAD astronomical database
- Quantum Fisher information matrix and multiparameter estimation
- First Light for GRAVITY: Phase Referencing Optical Interferometry for the Very Large Telescope Interferometer
- First Results from the CHARA Array. II. A Description of the Instrument
- Quantum Theory of Superresolution for Two Incoherent Optical Point Sources
- Longer-Baseline Telescopes Using Quantum Repeaters
- A Geometric Perspective on Quantum Parameter Estimation
- Far-field Superresolution of Thermal Electromagnetic Sources at the Quantum Limit
- Beating Rayleigh's Curse by Imaging Using Phase Information
- Multiparameter Quantum Metrology of Incoherent Point Sources: Towards Realistic Superresolution
- Optical Intensity Interferometry with the Cherenkov Telescope Array
- Resolving starlight: a quantum perspective
- Simple expression for the quantum Fisher information matrix
- Beating the Rayleigh Limit Using Two-Photon Interference
- Quantum-limited time-frequency estimation through mode-selective photon measurement
- Quantum-limited estimation of the axial separation of two incoherent point sources
- Towards superresolution surface metrology: Quantum estimation of angular and axial separations
- Super-resolving multi-photon interferences with independent light sources
- The quantum limit to incoherent imaging is achieved by linear interferometry
- Demonstration of stellar intensity interferometry with the four VERITAS telescopes
- A Lower Bound for the Fisher Information Measure
- Temporal intensity interferometry: photon bunching on three bright stars
- General expressions for the quantum Fisher information matrix with applications to discrete quantum imaging
- Measuring Temporal Photon Bunching in Blackbody Radiation
- Optical intensity interferometry observations using the MAGIC imaging atmospheric Cherenkov telescopes
- Imaging sub-milliarcsecond stellar features with intensity interferometry using air Cherenkov telescope arrays
- Intensity interferometry of P Cygni in the H emission line: towards distance calibration of LBV supergiant stars
- Optimal imaging of remote bodies using quantum detectors
- Spatial intensity interferometry on three bright stars
- Intensity interferometry with more than two detectors?
- Modal decomposition of a propagating matter wave via electron ptychography
- Optical Intensity Interferometry through Atmospheric Turbulence
- Optimal Quantum Metrology of Distant Black Bodies
- Non-Orthogonal Bases for Quantum Metrology
- Capabilities of future intensity interferometers for observing fast-rotating stars: imaging with two- and three-telescope correlations
- Intensity interferometry: Optical imaging with kilometer baselines
- Quantum-Assisted Optical Interferometers: Instrument Requirements
- Development of a Digital Astronomical Intensity Interferometer: laboratory tests with thermal light
- A 3.9 km baseline intensity interferometry photon counting experiment
- Science cases for a visible interferometer
- Astro2020 White Paper State of the Profession: Intensity Interferometry
Cited by in corpus (14)
- Optical quantum super-resolution imaging and hypothesis testing
- First Intensity Interferometry Measurements with the H.E.S.S. Telescopes
- Large baseline optical imaging assisted by single photons and linear quantum optics
- Astrometry in two-photon interferometry using Earth rotation fringe scan
- Quantum limits of parameter estimation in long-baseline imaging
- Towards Quantum Telescopes: Demonstration of a Two-Photon Interferometer for Quantum-Assisted Astronomy
- Super-Resolution Imaging with Multiparameter Quantum Metrology in Passive Remote Sensing
- Optical intensity interferometry lab tests in preparation of stellar diameter measurements at IACTs at GHz photon rates
- Superresolution imaging with entanglement-enhanced telescopy
- Tight information bounds for spontaneous emission lifetime resolution of quantum sources with varied spectral purity
- Quantum-enabled optical large-baseline interferometry: applications, protocols and feasibility
- Quantum resolution limit of long-baseline imaging using distributed entanglement
- Superresolution of unequal-brightness thermal sources for stellar interferometry
- Quantum-enhanced passive remote sensing