On the Willmore problem for surfaces with symmetry

Abstract

The Willmore Problem seeks the surface in ${\mathbb{S}}^3\subset {\mathbb{R}}^4$ of a given topological type minimizing the squared-mean-curvature energy $W=\int |{\mathbf{H}}_{{\mathbb{R}}^4}{|}^2=\mathrm{area}+\int H_{{\mathbb{S}}^3}^2$. The longstanding Willmore Conjecture that the Clifford torus minimizes $W$ among genus-$1$ surfaces is now a theorem of Marques and Neves [19], but the general conjecture [10] that Lawson's [16] minimal surface ${\xi }_{g,1}\subset {\mathbb{S}}^3$ minimizes $W$ among surfaces of genus $g>1$ remains open. Here we prove this conjecture under the additional assumption that the competitor surfaces $M\subset {\mathbb{S}}^3$ share the ambient symmetries of ${\xi }_{g,1}$. Specifcally, we show each Lawson surface ${\xi }_{m,k}$ satisfies the analogous $W$-minimizing property under a somewhat smaller symmetry group $G_{m,k}<SO(4)$, using a local computation of the orbifold Euler number ${\chi }_o(M/G_{m,k})$ to exclude certain intersection patterns of $M$ with the great circles fixed by generators of $G_{m,k}$. We also describe a genus 2 example where the Willmore Problem may not be solvable among surfaces with its symmetry.

We thank N. Kapouleas and D. Wiygul for pointing out a counterexample to the conclusion of our Lemma 4.5 stemming from overlooking part of the fixed-point set of the group action. This limits our method to a superset of the pairs (m,k) where one is odd and the other is even, and also requires symmetry under a subgroup of SO(4) containing G_{m,k} with index 2. We will submit a revised paper soon

References in corpus (2)

• New applications of Min-max Theory
• The Lawson surfaces are determined by their symmetries and topology