Can single photon excitation of two spatially separated modes lead to a violation of Bell inequality via homodyne measurements?

Abstract

We reconsider the all-optical homodyne-measurement based experimental schemes that aim to reveal Bell nonclassicality of a single photon, often termed `nonlocality'. We focus on the schemes put forward by Tan, Walls and Collett (TWC, 1991) and Hardy (1994). In the light of our previous work the Tan, Walls and Collett setup can be described by a precise local hidden variable model, hence the claimed nonclassicality of this proposal is apparent, whereas the nonclassicality proof proposed by Hardy is impeccable. In this work we resolve the following problem: which feature of the Hardy's approach is crucial for its successful confirmation of nonclassicality. The scheme of Hardy differs from the Tan, Walls and Collett setup in two aspects. (i) It introduces a superposition of a single photon excitation with vacuum as the initial state of one of the input modes of a 50-50 beamsplitter, which creates the superposition state of two separable (exit) modes under investigation. (ii) In the final measurements Hardy's proposal utilises a varying strengths of the local oscillator fields, whereas in the TWC case they are constant. In fact the local oscillators in Hardy's scheme are either on or off (the local setting is specified by the presence or absence of the local auxiliary field). We show that it is the varying strength of the local oscillators, from setting to setting, which is the crucial feature enabling violation of local realism in the Hardy setup, whereas it is not necessary to use initial superposition of a single photon excitation with vacuum as the initial state of the input mode. Neither one needs to operate in the fully on/off detection scheme. Despite the failure of the Tan, Walls and Collett scheme in proving Bell nonclassicality, we show that their scheme can serve as an entanglement indicator.

15 pages, 6 figures. Comments are welcome

References in corpus (12)

• Experimental interference of independent photons
• Experimental Proof of Nonlocal Wavefunction Collapse for a Single Particle Using Homodyne Measurement
• Nonlocality of a single particle
• EPR entanglement strategies in two-well BEC
• Witnessing trustworthy single-photon entanglement with local homodyne measurements
• Nonlocality of a single photon: paths to an EPR-steering experiment
• Observing optical coherence across Fock layers with weak-field homodyne detectors
• Operational formulation of homodyne detection
• Stochastic Electrodynamics: The Closest Classical Approximation to Quantum Theory
• Detecting mode entanglement: The role of coherent states, superselection rules and particle statistics
• Single-photon quantum nonlocality: Violation of the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality using feasible measurement setups
• No-go for device independent protocols with Tan-Walls-Collett `nonlocality of a single photon'

Cited by in corpus (15)

• Single-photon nonlocality in quantum networks
• How squeezed states both maximize and minimize the same notion of quantumness
• On detecting violation of local realism with photon-number resolving weak-field homodyne measurements
• Optimal interferometry for Bell$-$nonclassicality by a vacuum$-$one$-$photon qubit
• Comment on `Single particle nonlocality with completely independent reference states'
• Revisited aspects of the local set in CHSH Bell scenario
• CHSH Bell Tests For Optical Hybrid Entanglement
• On the Fidelity Robustness of CHSH--Bell Inequality via Filtered Random States
• "Nonlocality-of-a-single-photon" based Quantum Key Distribution and Random Number Generation schemes and their device-independent security analysis
• Insights into Quantum Contextuality and Bell Nonclassicality: A Study on Random Pure Two-Qubit Systems
• Noiseless Loss Suppression for Entanglement Distribution
• Testing Single Photon Entanglement using Self-Referential Measurements
• Unquestionable Bell theorem for interwoven frustrated down conversion processes
• Open dynamics of entanglement in mesoscopic bosonic systems
• Bosonic fields in states with undefined particle numbers possess detectable non-contextuality features, plus more