Integrating theory and experiments to link local mechanisms and ecosystem-level consequences of vegetation patterns in drylands

Abstract

Self-organized spatial patterns of vegetation are frequent in drylands and, because pattern shape correlates with water availability, they have been suggested as important indicators of ecosystem health. However, the mechanisms underlying pattern emergence remain unclear. Some theories hypothesize that patterns could result from a water-mediated scale-dependent feedback (SDF) whereby interactions favoring plant growth dominate at short distances and growth-inhibitory interactions dominate in the long range. However, we know little about how the presence of a focal plant affects the fitness of its neighbors as a function of the inter-individual distance, which is expected to be highly ecosystem-dependent. This lack of empirical knowledge and system dependency challenge the relevance of SDF as a unifying theory for vegetation pattern formation. Assuming that plant interactions are always inhibitory and only their intensity is scale-dependent, alternative theories also recover the typical vegetation patterns observed in nature. Importantly, although these alternative hypotheses lead to visually indistinguishable patterns, they predict contrasting desertification dynamics, which questions the potential use of vegetation patterns as ecosystem-state indicators. To help resolve this issue, we first review existing theories for vegetation self-organization and their conflicting predictions about desertification dynamics. Second, we discuss potential empirical tests via manipulative experiments to identify pattern-forming mechanisms and link them to specific desertification dynamics. A comprehensive view of models, the mechanisms they intend to capture, and experiments to test them in the field will help to better understand both how patterns emerge and improve predictions on the fate of the ecosystems where they form.

arXiv comment20 pages, 6 figures

References in corpus (22)

• Non-local Interaction Effects on Pattern Formation in Population Dynamics
• Clustering, advection and patterns in a model of population dynamics with neighborhood-dependent rates
• Species clustering in competitive Lotka-Volterra models
• Transitions between patterned states in vegetation models for semi-arid ecosystems
• Fairy circle landscapes under the sea
• Strong interaction between plants induces circular barren patches: fairy circles
• On localized vegetation patterns, fairy circles and localized patches in arid landscapes
• Species competition: coexistence, exclusion and clustering
• Vegetation pattern formation in semiarid systems without facilitative mechanisms
• Effects of precipitation intermittency on vegetation patterns in semi-arid landscapes
• Nonlocal competition and logistic growth: patterns, defects and fronts
• Minimal mechanisms for vegetation patterns in semiarid regions
• Plant clonal morphologies and spatial patterns as self-organized responses to resource-limited environments
• Assessing the robustness of spatial pattern sequences in a dryland vegetation model
• Dynamics of growth, death, and resource competition in sessile organisms
• Pattern formation and coexistence domains for a nonlocal population dynamics
• Spatial patterns in mesic savannas: the local facilitation limit and the role of demographic stochasticity
• Effects of quenched disorder on critical transitions in pattern-forming systems
• Formation of localized states in dryland vegetation: Bifurcation structure and stability
• Empirical analysis of vegetation dynamics and the possibility of a catastrophic desertification transition
• Interplay between scales in the nonlocal FKPP equation
• Single-species fragmentation: the role of density-dependent feedbacks

Cited by in corpus (7)

• Demographic effects of aggregation in the presence of a component Allee effect
• Aperiodic clustered and periodic hexagonal vegetation spot arrays explained by inhomogeneous environments and climate trends in arid ecosystems
• Pulsed interactions unify reaction-diffusion and spatial nonlocal models for biological pattern formation
• Flow spatial structure determines pattern instabilities in nonlocal models of population dynamics
• How spatial patterns can lead to less resilient ecosystems
• Decoding the interaction mediators from landscape-induced spatial patterns
• Vegetation pattern formation induced by local growth outpacing susceptibility to non-local competition