Comment on "Kosterlitz-Thouless-type caging-uncaging transition in a quasi-one-dimensional hard disk system" [Phys. Rev. Research 2, 033351 (2020)]

Abstract

Huerta et al. [Phys. Rev. Research 2, 033351 (2020)] report a power-law decay of positional order in numerical simulations of hard disks confined within hard parallel walls, which they interpret as a Kosterlitz-Thouless-type caging-uncaging transition. The proposed existence of such a transition in a quasi-one-dimensional (q1D) system, however, contradicts long-held physical expectations. To clarify if the proposed ordering persists in the thermodynamic limit, we introduce an exact transfer matrix approach to expeditiously generate equilibrium configurations for systems of arbitrary size. The power-law decay of positional order is found to extend only over finite distances. We conclude that the numerical simulation results reported are associated with a crossover, and not a proper thermodynamic phase transition.

5 pages, 3 figures

References in corpus (3)

• Understanding the ideal glass transition: Lessons from an equilibrium study of hard disks in a channel
• Analytical canonical partition function of a quasi-one dimensional system of hard disks
• Beyond the single-file fluid limit using transfer matrix method: Exact results for confined parallel hard squares

Cited by in corpus (11)

• Structural properties of hard-disk fluids under single-file confinement
• Exploring anisotropic pressure and spatial correlations in strongly confined hard-disk fluids. Exact results
• Universality of the close packing properties and markers of isotropic-to-tetratic crossover in quasi-one-dimensional superdisk fluid
• Canonical partition function and distance dependent correlation functions of a quasi-one-dimensional system of hard disks
• Ordering properties of anisotropic hard bodies in one-dimensional channels
• Monte Carlo simulation of Hard-, Square-Well, and Square-Shoulder Disks in narrow channels
• Competition between shape anisotropy and deformation in the ordering and close packing properties of quasi-one-dimensional hard superellipse fluids
• Orientational ordering and correlations in a quasi-one-dimensional hard-dumbbell fluid
• Algebraic to exponential decay of spatial correlations in one-dimensional and confined hard-core fluids: A Laplace-pole analysis
• Hard disks confined within a narrow channel
• Numerical transfer matrix study of frustrated next-nearest-neighbor Ising models on square lattices