Multistability and rare spontaneous transitions in barotropic $\beta$-plane turbulence

Abstract

We demonstrate that turbulent zonal jets, analogous to Jovian ones, which are quasi-stationary, are actually metastable. After extremely long times, they randomly switch to new configurations with a different number of jets. The genericity of this phenomenon suggests that most quasi-stationary turbulent planetary atmospheres might have many climates and attractors for fixed values of the external forcing parameters. A key message is that this situation will usually not be detected by simply running the numerical models, because of the extremely long mean transition time to change from one climate to another. In order to study such phenomena, we need to use specific tools: rare event algorithms and large deviation theory. With these tools, we make a full statistical mechanics study of a classical barotropic beta-plane quasigeostrophic model. It exhibits robust bimodality with abrupt transitions. We show that new jets spontaneously nucleate from westward jets. The numerically computed mean transition time is consistent with an Arrhenius law showing an exponential decrease of the probability as the Ekman dissipation decreases. This phenomenology is controlled by rare noise-driven paths called {\it instantons}. Moreover, we compute the saddles of the corresponding effective dynamics. For the dynamics of states with three alternating jets, we uncover an unexpectedly rich dynamics governed by the symmetric group ${\mathcal{S}}_3$ of permutations, with two distinct families of instantons, which is a surprise for a system where everything seemed stationary in the hundreds of previous simulations of this model. We discuss the future generalization of our approach to more realistic models.

arXiv commentSubmitted to Journal of Atmospheric Science, 38 pages, 21 figures. Version 3 corresponds to the version accepted in the Journal of Atmospheric Science, metadata are changed

References in corpus (29)

• Turbulence transition and the edge of chaos in pipe flow
• Computation of extreme heat waves in climate models using a large deviation algorithm
• Multistability and memory effect in a highly turbulent flow: experimental evidence for a global bifurcation
• Random changes of flow topology in two dimensional and geophysical turbulence
• Direct Statistical Simulation of Out-of-Equilibrium Jets
• Edge States in the Climate System: Exploring Global Instabilities and Critical Transitions
• Numerical computation of rare events via large deviation theory
• Universal profile of the vortex condensate in two-dimensional turbulence
• A rare event algorithm links transitions in turbulent flows with activated nucleations
• A multiple replica approach to simulate reactive trajectories
• Kinetic theory of jet dynamics in the stochastic barotropic and 2D Navier-Stokes equations
• Zonal Flow as Pattern Formation
• Emergence and equilibration of jets in beta-plane turbulence: applications of Stochastic Structural Stability Theory
• Practical rare event sampling for extreme mesoscale weather
• Computing transition rates for the 1-D stochastic Ginzburg--Landau--Allen--Cahn equation for finite-amplitude noise with a rare event algorithm
• Langevin dynamics, large deviations and instantons for the quasi-geostrophic model and two-dimensional Euler equations
• Vortex-density fluctuations, energy spectra and vortical regions in superfluid turbulence
• Computation of rare transitions in the barotropic quasi-geostrophic equations
• Statistical behavior of adaptive multilevel splitting algorithms in simple models
• A theory for the emergence of coherent structures in beta-plane turbulence
• Is the Boltzmann equation reversible? A large deviation perspective on the irreversibility paradox
• Zonal jets at the laboratory scale: hysteresis and Rossby waves resonance
• Atmospheric bistability and abrupt transitions to superrotation: wave-jet resonance and Hadley cell feedbacks
• Computation of extremes values of time averaged observables in climate models with large deviation techniques
• Instanton based importance sampling for rare events in stochastic PDEs
• Maximizing simulated tropical cyclone intensity with action minimization
• Numerical study of extreme mechanical force exerted by a turbulent flow on a bluff body by direct and rare-event sampling techniques
• Instantons for the destabilization of the inner Solar System
• Fluctuations and large deviations of Reynolds stresses in zonal jet dynamics

Cited by in corpus (10)

• Extreme events in transitional turbulence
• Instantons and the path to intermittency in turbulent flows
• Coupling rare event algorithms with data-based learned committor functions using the analogue Markov chain
• Collapse of transitional wall turbulence captured using a rare events algorithm
• Path integral derivation and numerical computation of large deviation prefactors for non-equilibrium dynamics through matrix Riccati equations
• Intrinsic oceanic decadal variability of upper-ocean heat content
• Data-driven methods to estimate the committor function in conceptual ocean models
• Computing non-equilibrium trajectories by a deep learning approach
• Does rare, noise-induced, bypass transition in plane Couette flow bypass instantons ?
• Kinetic Random-Field Nonreciprocal Ising Model