Internality, transfer, and infinitesimal modeling of infinite processes
arXiv:2008.11513 · doi:10.1093/philmat/nkaa033
Abstract
A probability model is underdetermined when there is no rational reason to assign a particular infinitesimal value as the probability of single events. Pruss claims that hyperreal probabilities are underdetermined. The claim is based upon external hyperreal-valued measures. We show that internal hyperfinite measures are not underdetermined. The importance of internality stems from the fact that Robinson's transfer principle only applies to internal entities. We also evaluate the claim that transferless ordered fields (surreals, Levi-Civita field, Laurent series) may have advantages over hyperreals in probabilistic modeling. We show that probabilities developed over such fields are less expressive than hyperreal probabilities.
arXiv comment25 pages; to appear in Philosophia Mathematica
References in corpus (5)
- Non-Archimedean Probability
- Integration on the Surreals: a Conjecture of Conway, Kruskal and Norton
- On mathematical realism and the applicability of hyperreals
- Infinite lotteries, spinners, and the applicability of hyperreals
- Lebesgue measure theory and integration theory on non-archimedean real closed fields with archimedean value group