Approximating Power Flow and Transmission Losses in Coordinated Capacity Expansion Problems

Abstract

With rising shares of renewables and the need to properly assess trade-offs between transmission, storage and sectoral integration as balancing options, building a bridge between energy system models and detailed power flow studies becomes increasingly important, but is computationally challenging. W compare approximations for two nonlinear phenomena, power flow and transmission losses, in linear capacity expansion problems that co-optimise investments in generation, storage and transmission infrastructure. We evaluate different flow representations discussing differences in investment decisions, nodal prices, the deviation of optimised flows and losses from simulated AC power flows, and the computational performance. By using the open European power system model PyPSA-Eur we obtain detailed and reproducible results aiming at facilitating the selection of a suitable power flow model. Given the differences in complexity, the optimal choice depends on the application, the user's available computational resources, and the level of spatial detail considered. Although the commonly used transport model can already identify key features of a cost-efficient system while being computationally performant, deficiencies under high loading conditions arise due to the lack of a physical grid representation. Moreover, disregarding transmission losses overestimates optimal grid expansion by 20%. Adding a convex relaxation of quadratic losses with two or three tangents to the linearised power flow equations and accounting for changing line impedances as the network is reinforced suffices to represent power flows and losses adequately in design studies. We show that the obtained investment and dispatch decisions are then sufficiently physical to be used in more detailed nonlinear simulations of AC power flow in order to better assess their technical feasibility.

arXiv commentaddresses the need for detailed grid modelling in linear energy system models

References in corpus (12)

• Synergies of sector coupling and transmission reinforcement in a cost-optimised, highly renewable European energy system
• PyPSA: Python for Power System Analysis
• Response to 'Burden of proof: A comprehensive review of the feasibility of 100% renewable-electricity systems'
• PyPSA-Eur: An Open Optimisation Model of the European Transmission System
• Impact of different time series aggregation methods on optimal energy system design
• The Benefits of Cooperation in a Highly Renewable European Electricity Network
• Time series aggregation for energy system design: Modeling seasonal storage
• The strong effect of network resolution on electricity system models with high shares of wind and solar
• The role of spatial scale in joint optimisations of generation and transmission for European highly renewable scenarios
• Linear Optimal Power Flow Using Cycle Flows
• Linear/Quadratic Programming-Based Optimal Power Flow using Linear Power Flow and Absolute Loss Approximations
• Lossy DC Power Flow

Cited by in corpus (12)

• PyPSA-Earth. A New Global Open Energy System Optimization Model Demonstrated in Africa
• Are biofuel mandates cost-effective? -- an analysis of transport fuels and biomass usage to achieve emissions targets in the European energy system
• Energy Imports and Infrastructure in a Carbon-Neutral European Energy System
• A computationally efficient Benders decomposition for energy systems planning problems with detailed operations and time-coupling constraints
• Chance Constrained Economic Dispatch Considering the Capability of Network Flexibility Against Renewable Uncertainties
• Regularized Benders Decomposition for High Performance Capacity Expansion Models
• Cost and efficiency requirements for a successful electricity storage in a highly renewable European energy system
• REMIND-PyPSA-Eur: Integrating power system flexibility into sector-coupled energy transition pathways
• Reducing energy system model distortions from unintended storage cycling through variable costs
• PyPSA-DE: Open-source German energy system model reveals savings from integrated planning
• Modeling of Network Constraints in Large-scale Capacity Expansion Optimization of Power Grids
• Community Detection in Energy Networks based on Energy Self-Sufficiency and Dynamic Flexibility Activation