Misconceptions on Effective Field Theories and spontaneous symmetry breaking: Response to Ellis' article

Abstract

In an earlier paper~\cite{Luu:2019jmb} we discussed emergence from the context of effective field theories, particularly as related to the fields of particle and nuclear physics. We argued on the side of reductionism and weak emergence. George Ellis has critiqued our exposition in~\cite{Ellis:2020vij}, and here we provide our response to his critiques. Many of his critiques are based on incorrect assumptions related to the formalism of effective field theories and we attempt to correct these issues here. We also comment on other statements made in his paper. Important to note is that our response is to his critiques made in archive versions arXiv:2004.13591v1-5 [physics.hist-ph]. That is, versions 1-5 of this archive post. Version 6 has similar content as versions 1-5, but versions 7-9 are seemingly a different paper altogether (even with a different title).

arXiv comment15 pages, link in abstract corrected

References in corpus (24)

• Topological Field Theory of Time-Reversal Invariant Insulators
• Topological insulators and superconductors: ten-fold way and dimensional hierarchy
• Effective Field Theory for Few-Nucleon Systems
• Measurement of the permanent electric dipole moment of the neutron
• Ab initio calculation of the Hoyle state
• On the Foundations of Chiral Perturbation Theory
• Revised and Improved Value of the QED Tenth-Order Electron Anomalous Magnetic Moment
• Nonrelativistic effective Lagrangians
• Unraveling models of CP violation through electric dipole moments of light nuclei
• Effective Field Theory for Dilute Fermi Systems
• Superfluidity and Superconductivity in Neutron Stars
• The Born-Oppenheimer approximation in an effective field theory language
• Standard Model Gauging of the WZW Term: Anomalies, Global Currents and pseudo-Chern-Simons Interactions
• Dynamics of the inner crust of neutron stars: hydrodynamics, elasticity and collective modes
• Two-Hole Bound States from a Systematic Low-Energy Effective Field Theory for Magnons and Holes in an Antiferromagnet
• Turning the nuclear energy density functional method into a proper effective field theory: reflections
• Precision calculation of the axion-nucleon coupling in chiral perturbation theory
• Quasiparticle Properties in Effective Field Theory
• Self-consistent formulations for stochastic nonlinear neuronal dynamics
• Derivation of the effective action of a dilute Fermi gas in the unitary limit of the BCS-BEC crossover
• Fractional quantum Hall effect in a relativistic field theory
• Effective Field Theory of 2D van Hove Singularities
• Wilsonian effective field theory of 2D van Hove singularities
• SU(3)/SU(2): the simplest Wess-Zumino-Witten term