Uniqueness in Haken's Theorem

Abstract

Following Haken and Casson-Gordon, it was shown in [Sc] that given a reducing sphere or boundary-reducing disk E in a Heegaard split manifold M, the Heegaard surface T can be isotoped so that it intersects E in a single circle. Here we show that when this is achieved by two different positionings of T, one can be moved to the other by a sequence of 1) isotopies of T rel E 2) pushing a stabilizing pair of T through E and 3) eyegelass twists of T. The last move is inspired by one of Powell's proposed generators for the Goeritz group.

This version improves exposition and corrects typos, following referee's comments