Insights into the "cross-world" independence assumption of causal mediation analysis

Abstract

Causal mediation analysis is a useful tool for epidemiological research, but it has been criticized for relying on a "cross-world" independence assumption that is empirically difficult to verify and problematic to justify based on background knowledge. In the present article we aim to assist the applied researcher in understanding this assumption. Synthesizing what is known about the cross-world independence assumption, we discuss the relationship between assumptions for causal mediation analyses, causal models, and non-parametric identification of natural direct and indirect effects. In particular we give a practical example of an applied setting where the cross-world independence assumption is violated even without any post-treatment confounding. Further, we review possible alternatives to the cross-world independence assumption, including the use of computation of bounds that avoid the assumption altogether. Finally, we carry out a numerical study in which the cross-world independence assumption is violated to assess the ensuing bias in estimating natural direct and indirect effects. We conclude with recommendations for carrying out causal mediation analyses.

References in corpus (7)

• Identification, Inference and Sensitivity Analysis for Causal Mediation Effects
• Semiparametric theory for causal mediation analysis: Efficiency bounds, multiple robustness and sensitivity analysis
• Direct and Indirect Effects of Sequential Treatments
• Time-dependent mediators in survival analysis: Modelling direct and indirect effects with the additive hazards model
• Sensitivity analysis for unobserved confounding of direct and indirect effects using uncertainty intervals
• Generalized interpretation and identification of separable effects in competing event settings
• On Partial Identification of the Pure Direct Effect

Cited by in corpus (4)

• Heterogeneous Indirect Effects for Multiple Mediators using Interventional Effect Models
• Mediation analysis with case-control sampling: Identification and estimation in the presence of a binary mediator
• A Bayesian Joint Model for Compositional Mediation Effect Selection in Microbiome Data
• Interval identification of natural effects in the presence of outcome-related unmeasured confounding