Ghost from constraints: a generalization of Ostrogradsky theorem

Abstract

Ostrogradsky theorem states that Hamiltonian is unbounded when Euler-Lagrange equations are higher than second-order differential equations under the nondegeneracy assumption. Since higher-order nondegenerate Lagrangian can be always recast into an equivalent system with at most first-order derivatives by introducing auxiliary variables and constraints, it is conceivable that the link between ghost and higher derivatives may be reinterpreted as a link between ghost and constraints and/or auxiliary variables. We find that the latter point of view actually provides more general perspective than the former, by exploring the un/boundedness of the Hamiltonian for general theories containing auxiliary variables, for which Euler-Lagrange equations can be essentially second order or lower than that. For Lagrangians including auxiliary variables nonlinearly, we derive the degeneracy condition to evade the Ostrogradsky ghost that can apply even if auxiliary variables can be solved only locally. For theories with constraints with Lagrange multipliers, we establish criteria for inclusion of nonholonomic (velocity-dependent) constraints leading to the absence of local minimum of Hamiltonian. Our criteria include the Ostrogradsky theorem as a special case, and can detect not only ghost associated with higher-order derivatives, but also ghost coming from lower-order derivatives in system with constraints. We discuss how to evade such a ghost. We also provide various specific examples to highlight application and limitation of our general arguments.

28 pages, 1 figure, improved discussions, accepted for publication in JCAP

References in corpus (11)

• Beyond the Cosmological Standard Model
• Degenerate higher order scalar-tensor theories beyond Horndeski up to cubic order
• Mimetic gravity: a review of recent developments and applications to cosmology and astrophysics
• Dark energy from modified gravity with Lagrange multipliers
• Third order equations of motion and the Ostrogradsky instability
• Extended mimetic gravity: Hamiltonian analysis and gradient instabilities
• Mimetic dark matter, ghost instability and a mimetic tensor-vector-scalar gravity
• On the Quantisation of Complex Higher Derivative Theories and Avoiding the Ostrogradsky Ghost
• A Covariant Master Theory for Novel Galilean Invariant Models and Massive Gravity
• Classical and Quantum Dynamics of Higher-Derivative Systems
• Hamiltonian analysis of mimetic scalar gravity revisited

Cited by in corpus (10)

• Black hole perturbations in DHOST theories: Master variables, gradient instability, and strong coupling
• Stealth dark energy in scordatura DHOST theory
• Inflation with $0\le c_{\mathrm{s}}\le 1$
• Consistency of higher derivative couplings to matter fields in scalar-tensor gravity
• Chiral Gravitational Waves in Palatini Chern-Simons
• Black hole perturbations in higher-order scalar-tensor theories: initial value problem and dynamical stability
• Black hole ringdown from physically sensible initial value problem in higher-order scalar-tensor theories
• Exact solution for rotating black holes in parity-violating gravity
• Removal of instabilities of the higher derivative theories in the light of antilinearity
• Probing higher curvature gravity via ringdown with overtones