A Critique of the Asymptotic Safety Program

Abstract

The present practice of Asymptotic Safety in gravity is in conflict with explicit calculations in low energy quantum gravity. This raises the question of whether the present practice meets the Weinberg condition for Asymptotic Safety. I argue, with examples, that the running of $\Lambda$ and $G$ found in Asymptotic Safety are not realized in the real world, with reasons which are relatively simple to understand. A comparison/contrast with quadratic gravity is also given, which suggests a few obstacles that must be overcome before the Lorentzian version of the theory is well behaved. I make a suggestion on how a Lorentzian version of Asymptotic Safety could potentially solve these problems.

arXiv comment40 pages, 1 figure. Final version as published

References in corpus (45)

• Exact evolution equation for the effective potential
• General relativity as an effective field theory: The leading quantum corrections
• Nonperturbative Evolution Equation for Quantum Gravity
• Quantum Gravitational Corrections to the Nonrelativistic Scattering Potential of Two Masses
• Asymptotic safety in higher-derivative gravity
• Fixed Points of Higher Derivative Gravity
• Agravity
• Asymptotic safety guaranteed
• On-shell Techniques and Universal Results in Quantum Gravity
• Aspects of Quadratic Gravity
• Quadratic Gravity
• Gravitational Correction to Running of Gauge Couplings
• Calculation of Graviton Scattering Amplitudes using String-Based Methods
• Bending of Light in Quantum Gravity
• Towards apparent convergence in asymptotically safe quantum gravity
• Unitarity, stability and loops of unstable ghosts
• Resolving Spacetime Singularities within Asymptotic Safety
• Aspects of asymptotic safety for quantum gravity
• Running Gauge Coupling in Asymptotically Safe Quantum Gravity
• Form Factors in Asymptotic Safety: conceptual ideas and computational toolbox
• Causality as an emergent macroscopic phenomenon: The Lee-Wick O(N) model
• Gauge Dependence of Gravitational Correction to Running of Gauge Couplings
• Quantum gravitational contributions to quantum electrodynamics
• Absence of gravitational contributions to the running Yang-Mills coupling
• A QCD analogy for quantum gravity
• Infinities within graviton scattering amplitudes
• Quantum gravity and charge renormalization
• On the running of the gravitational constant
• The arrow of causality and quantum gravity
• Vacuum energy and relativistic invariance
• Naturalness and Dimensional Transmutation in Classically Scale-Invariant Gravity
• Running couplings and operator mixing in the gravitational corrections to coupling constants
• EPFL Lectures on General Relativity as a Quantum Field Theory
• On the non-local heat kernel expansion
• Gravitational Corrections to Yukawa and Phi^4 Interactions
• Analytic continuation of functional renormalization group equations
• Considerations Concerning the Contributions of Fundamental Particles to the Vacuum Energy Density
• Gauge Assisted Quadratic Gravity: A Framework for UV Complete Quantum Gravity
• Gravitational Contributions to the Running of Gauge Couplings
• Computing the Effective Action with the Functional Renormalization Group
• More on the Bending of Light in Quantum Gravity
• Quantum scale symmetry
• Quadratic gravity: from weak to strong
• Graviton Bending in Quantum Gravity from One-Loop Amplitudes
• Gauge-Invariant Quantum Gravity Corrections to Gauge Couplings via Vilkovisky-DeWitt Method and Gravity Assisted Gauge Unification

Cited by in corpus (60)

• The nonperturbative functional renormalization group and its applications
• Quantum gravity: a fluctuating point of view
• Non-perturbative unitarity and fictitious ghosts in quantum gravity
• Unimodular Gravity vs General Relativity: A status report
• Finite Quantum Gravity Amplitudes -- no strings attached
• Constraining power of asymptotic safety for scalar fields
• Essential Quantum Einstein Gravity
• Safety in darkness: Higgs portal to simple Yukawa systems
• Generalized uncertainty principle and Asymptotic Safe gravity
• Essential renormalisation group
• Asymptotic Safety: Swampland or Wonderland?
• Scalar-Tensor theories within Asymptotic Safety
• Graviton-Mediated Scattering Amplitudes from the Quantum Effective Action
• Predictive power of grand unification from quantum gravity
• Naturally small Yukawa couplings from trans-Planckian asymptotic safety
• Cosmological consequences of a principle of finite amplitudes
• Relational observables in Asymptotically safe gravity
• Formation and evaporation of quantum black holes from the decoupling mechanism in quantum gravity
• Running Newton Coupling, Scale Identification and Black Hole Thermodynamics
• Exploring new corners of asymptotically safe unimodular quantum gravity
• Lessons from conformally reduced quantum gravity
• The cosmological constant and the use of cutoffs
• CFTs Blueshift Tensor Fluctuations Universally
• Gravity in $d=2+\epsilon$ dimensions and realizations of the diffeomorphisms group
• An algebraic QFT approach to the Wetterich equation on Lorentzian manifolds
• Tests For Maximum Force and Maximum Power
• The Effective Theory of Quantum Black Holes
• Constraints on $Z^{\prime }$ solutions to the flavor anomalies with trans-Planckian asymptotic safety
• Effective field equations and scale-dependent couplings in gravity
• FeynGrav 2.0
• The phase diagram of the multi-matrix model with ABAB-interaction from functional renormalization
• How robust are particle physics predictions in asymptotic safety?
• Planck Stars from a Scale-dependent Gravity theory
• Gravitational corrections to a non-Abelian gauge theory
• Notes on conformal anomaly, nonlocal effective action and the metamorphosis of the running scale
• Towards a unitary, renormalizable and ultraviolet-complete quantum theory of gravity
• Perturbative Asymptotic Safety and Its Phenomenological Applications
• The search for the universality class of metric quantum gravity
• From maximum force to the field equations of general relativity -- and implications
• Shift-symmetric Horndeski gravity in the asymptotic-safety paradigm
• Gravitational corrections to the Einstein-Scalar-QCD model
• Regular black hole from a confined spin connection in Poincare gauge gravity
• Image of Quantum Improved Regular Kerr Black Hole and Parameter Constraints from EHT Observations
• Lectures in Quantum Gravity
• Towards a Higgs mass determination in asymptotically safe gravity with a dark portal
• The weak-gravity bound and the need for spin in asymptotically safe matter-gravity models
• Ruling out models of vector dark matter in asymptotically safe quantum gravity
• Spectral Analysis of Quasinormal Modes of Planck Stars
• Conformal Cores of Quantum Black Holes in Quadratic Gravity
• Stabilizing dark matter with quantum scale symmetry
• Equivalence of scalar-tensor theories and scale-dependent gravity
• Lectures on Naturalness, String Landscape and Multiverse
• Strict renormalizability as a paradigm for fundamental physics
• Second resonance of the Higgs field: motivations, experimental signals, unitarity constraints
• Quantum Gravity, Hydrodynamics and Emergent Cosmology: A Collection of Perspectives
• Asymptotic safety and quantum gravity amplitudes
• A Universe from a Lagrangian Fixed Point
• Causality, unitarity and stability in quantum gravity: a non-perturbative perspective
• Three models of non-perturbative quantum-gravitational binding
• Gauges for quadratic gravity: the extended transverse gauge and the energy-momentum tensor of the massive spin-2 field