Holism as the significance of gauge symmetries
arXiv:1910.05330 · doi:10.1007/s13194-021-00397-y
Abstract
Not all symmetries are on a par. For instance, within Newtonian mechanics, we seem to have a good grasp on the empirical significance of boosts, by applying it to subsystems. This is exemplified by the thought experiment known as Galileo's ship: the inertial state of motion of a ship is immaterial to how events unfold in the cabin, but is registered in the values of relational quantities such as the distance and velocity of the ship relative to the shore. But the significance of gauge symmetries seems less clear. For example, can gauge transformations in Yang-Mills theory---taken as mere descriptive redundancy---exhibit a similar relational empirical significance as the boosts of Galileo's ship? This question has been debated in the last fifteen years in philosophy of physics. I will argue that the answer is `yes', but only for a finite subset of gauge transformations, and under special conditions. Under those conditions, we can mathematically identify empirical significance with a failure of supervenience: the state of the Universe is not uniquely determined by the intrinsic state of its isolated subsystems. Empirical significance is therefore encoded in those relations between subsystems that stand apart from their intrinsic states.
arXiv comment29 pages, 4 page appendix, 1 figure. V2: Argument streamlined and new counter-examples to previous definitions of DES through quotients
References in corpus (16)
- Invariant Variation Problems
- Covariant theory of asymptotic symmetries, conservation laws and central charges
- Local subsystems in gauge theory and gravity
- Symmetries in Physics: Philosophical Reflections
- Edge states in Gravity and Black Hole Physics
- Why Gauge?
- Noether's Theorems and Gauge Symmetries
- A unified geometric framework for boundary charges and dressings: non-Abelian theory and matter
- The Observer's Ghost: a field-space connection-form and its application to gauge theories and general relativity
- Artificial vs Substantial Gauge Symmetries: a Criterion and an Application to the Electroweak Model
- Gauging the Boundary in Field-space
- Permanent Underdetermination from Approximate Empirical Equivalence in Field Theory: Massless and Massive Scalar Gravity, Neutrino, Electromagnetic, Yang-Mills and Gravitational Theories
- Asymptotic Symmetry Groups of Long-Ranged Gauge Configurations
- The dressing field method of gauge symmetry reduction, a review with examples
- Soft charges from the geometry of field space
- The quasilocal degrees of freedom of Yang-Mills theory
Cited by in corpus (8)
- Edge modes as reference frames and boundary actions from post-selection
- Gauge Symmetries, Symmetry Breaking, and Gauge-Invariant Approaches
- Edge modes as dynamical frames: charges from post-selection in generally covariant theories
- Respecting Boundaries: Theoretical Equivalence and Structure Beyond Dynamics
- Reversing the Arrow of Time
- Note on the bundle geometry of field space, variational connections, the dressing field method, & presymplectic structures of gauge theories over bounded regions
- Soft edges: the many links between soft and edge modes
- Is spacetime curved? Assessing the underdetermination of general relativity and teleparallel gravity